Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Distal femoral fractures suffer high complication risks induced by stress shielding of high-modulus titanium locking plates. This work aimed to compare the biomechanical performance of four PEEK-series plates and titanium alloy implants for distal femoral fracture fixation, and establish material selection strategy. A Sawbones synthetic femur was fabricated into a comminuted fracture model. Four locking plates including pure PEEK, toughened CFR-PEEK, layered anisotropic PEEK and titanium alloy were analyzed via finite element simulation and 1000 N axial compression tests. Results showed that structural stiffness saturated at 20–110 GPa: modulus elevation from 6 to 20 GPa brought 28.4% stiffness improvement, while modulus increasing to 110 GPa only gained extra 9.8% stiffness. Toughened CFR-PEEK presented structural stiffness similar to titanium plates (femoral head displacement: 0.75 mm vs 0.69 mm), and lower stress shielding (peri-fracture bone stress: 40.2 MPa vs 30.9 MPa). Layered anisotropic PEEK suffered excessive plate stress (683.5 MPa) and unstable deformation, while pure PEEK lacked bearing capacity. In conclusion, toughened CFR-PEEK with elastic modulus above 20 GPa is a qualified substitute for titanium plates, which can balance fixation stability and stress shielding reduction for distal femoral fracture treatment. The research results propose a new approach to selecting bone plate materials: for isotropic materials, selecting an elastic modulus within the stiffness saturation range can achieve mechanical properties comparable to those of traditional metal bone plates while mitigating the stress shielding effect; for anisotropic materials, improving flexural strength can enhance structural stiffness while also mitigating the stress shielding effect.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Shi et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: