Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This Connexion paper interrogates how transparency initiatives produce and organise secrecy within renewable-energy supply chains. Challenging the assumed opposition between secrecy and transparency and focussing on the Global South, where many of the raw materials and much of the extraction and labour underpinning the renewable energy transition is concentrated, we show how transparency practices can reproduce the very inequalities and harms they ostensibly seek to address. We identify three dimensions of the secrecy-transparency nexus, and the underlying mechanisms that make each possible: (1) secrecy as regulated transparency , produced through legal mechanisms; (2) secrecy as redirected transparency , produced through deflective mechanisms; and (3) secrecy as deferred transparency , produced through temporal mechanisms. This Connexion paper makes two contributions. First, it extends extant research on the secrecy-transparency nexus by specifying the distinct yet interwoven forms of organising through which transparency organises and sustains secrecy. Second, it highlights the increasingly complex and asymmetric relationships between the Global North and the Global South that are continuously reproduced, and concealed within, ‘global’ efforts towards low-carbon transition. It reveals how existing climate governance of renewable-energy production can continually entrap the Global South in a position that is both structurally indispensable and vulnerable. We conclude by reflecting on two politically consequential directions for research: emerging forms of climate denial that produce what we term the ‘denial of denial’, and re-envisioning how Global South actors might reclaim agency.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Fan et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: