Key result
Composite valve graft procedures shift toward bioprostheses, with lower operative mortality in elective repairs than dissections.
Why the study?
Composite valve graft is the dominant approach for aortic root replacement, but selection between mechanical and bioprosthetic options remains an area of active debate, especially as TAVR introduces the possibility of valve-in-root intervention.
This review and retrospective analysis of 1,250 procedures highlights a contemporary shift toward bioprosthetic over mechanical composite valve grafts for the Bentall procedure, driven in part by the availability of future transcatheter valve-in-root interventions.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Elective timing may lower mortality in composite valve graft procedures; leaves open optimal prosthesis selection pending prospective trials.
Aortic root replacement has undergone an impressive evolution since the pioneering efforts of Bentall, De Bono, and others with the introduction of the composite valve graft (CVG) and subsequent refinements in coronary artery reimplantation. The commercial development of mechanical CVGs and, later, bioprosthetic CVGs has aided repair, which for most patients is centered on treating aneurysmal disease, the loss of leaflet coaptation related to annular dilatation, and aortic valve regurgitation. Indications for repair are determined by root diameter, the rate of aortic dilatation, symptoms, and underlying pathology. Operative thresholds also vary according to patient-specific factors such as age, heritable thoracic aortic disease, and bicuspid aortic valve. Of the many options for aortic root replacement, CVG is the dominant approach; however, the selection between mechanical and bioprosthetic options remains an area of active debate. Transcatheter aortic valve replacement (TAVR) has significantly influenced surgical decision-making by introducing the possibility of valve-in-root intervention after bioprosthetic CVG repair. Traditional practice generally favors mechanical CVG in younger patients due to superior durability, whereas bioprosthetic CVG is typically used in older patients and those seeking to avoid lifelong anticoagulation despite a higher risk of late valvular dysfunction. We retrospectively examined our experience with 1250 CVG procedures from 1990 to 2026 and found a shift from mechanical to bioprosthetic CVG repair in contemporary practice. Benchmark outcomes after CVG vary substantially according to patient baseline characteristics and operative complexity, with lower operative mortality rates for elective aneurysm repairs and higher rates for patients with acute type A dissection, nonelective repair, redo sternotomy, or concomitant cardiac surgery. This review summarizes the historical evolution, indications, surgical decision-making, technical considerations, and benchmark outcomes surrounding the Bentall operation.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
COSELLI et al. (2026) conducted a review in Aortic root disease (aneurysmal disease, annular dilatation, aortic valve regurgitation, acute type A dissection) (n=1,250). Composite valve graft (CVG) aortic root replacement (Bentall procedure) vs. Mechanical vs. bioprosthetic composite valve graft was evaluated on Operative mortality and shift in prosthesis selection. Composite valve graft procedures (n=1,250 from 1990-2026) shifted from mechanical to bioprosthetic repair, with lower operative mortality in elective aneurysm repairs than in acute dissections.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: