Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The challenges of safeguarding young people harmed in extra-familial contexts and relationships are an international concern. In this paper, we theorise these challenges, using care ethics to articulate why commitments to protect young people from extra-familial harm have not resulted in systems that care for them. We analyse data from a three-strand UK study that used action-research, participatory and arts-based methods to examine social work responses to extra-familial harm, including practice observations, social work assessments, interviews and focus groups with practitioners, young people and parents/carers and digital diary entries from social workers. We apply Tronto’s institutional framing of care ethics to analyse the data collected in respect of power, purposiveness, and plurality, and identify themes that they share; namely that responses to extra-familial harm marginalise young people impacted; prioritise risk over needs; and struggle to utilise or develop caring contexts relevant to different young people. Using these findings, we present the first ‘care matrix for extra-familial harm’ and argue for the prioritisation of services and systems that provide care for children impacted by extra-familial harm because we care about them – not because we are legally bound to do so.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Firmin et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: