Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Summary This article examines the potential for ecological social work within neoliberal systems through an analysis of Contextual Safeguarding, a framework developed in the United Kingdom to address adolescent harm beyond the family home. Drawing on a 2-year qualitative study with over 60 practitioners, the analysis applies Ungar’s deep ecology framework to explore how social workers conceptualise and enact contextual, systems-oriented practice within neoliberal service environments. Social workers found ecological approaches both professionally sustaining and personally taxing: while contextual safeguarding offered a hopeful, values-based vision of practice, implementing it within individualised and risk-focused systems generated profound contradictions, pressures and emotional burdens. Findings The paper evidences a contrast between the generative potential of ecological approaches and the constraints of systems. Practitioners could recognise young people’s value, develop interventions and build alliances. However, these were undermined by power relations, bureaucratic processes, misaligned agencies and politicised policy contexts, causing strain, powerlessness and exhaustion. Three tensions emerged between 1) localised responses to harm and standardised practice models; 2) holistic recognition of young people’s circumstances and de-contextualised, individualistic responses and 3) social workers relinquishing power when positioned as relatively powerless within the hierarchies of child welfare institutions. Applications The study provides a framework for leaders and practitioners to understand the tensions between ecological aspirations and neoliberal welfare systems. By making visible the structural sources of ethical strain and exhaustion, it supports practitioners to resist personal blame for system failure. The accounts of hopeful practice provide inspiration for a social work future aligned with global movements seeking relational, reciprocal and community-connected approaches.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Owens et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: