Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Selective discrimination of Ca2+ from Mg2+ remains challenging in saline matrices because both ions exhibit similar coordination behaviour and their chelation responses can be altered by solution conditions. EDTA and EGTA were systematically compared for Ca2+ and Mg2+ complexometric titration over 0-1000 ppm. The effects of pH (3-12), temperature (25-45 °C), NaCl (0-30 mM), KCl (0-19 000 mg L-1), SO42- (0-2700 mg L-1), and K+ (0-600 mg L-1) were evaluated in individual and equimolar Ca2+ : Mg2+ systems. Both chelators produced highly linear calibrations, but their responses differed markedly. EGTA increased Ca2+ calibration sensitivity by 32.9% relative to EDTA and showed substantially greater thermal stability. EDTA responded to both metals across pH 3-12, whereas EGTA produced no measurable Mg2+ endpoint at pH 3-7. Crucially, this Ca2+-selective response persisted in mixed Ca2+ : Mg2+ solutions containing chloride, sulphate, and potassium at the investigated concentrations. The study identifies an experimentally observed operational selectivity interval at pH 3-7, defined by differential endpoint detectability, in which Ca2+ remains measurable with EGTA while no stable visual Mg2+ endpoint is obtained under the investigated conditions. This matrix-resilient behaviour provides a practical basis for selective calcium analysis and future Ca2+/Mg2+ separation strategies.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Albalawi et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: