Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
To distinguish procedural capabilities, observed results, measurement provenance and data-access conditions in surgical robotics publications. We audited 180 retained PubMed publications, 45 per specialty. Eligible original reports evaluated physical surgical robot use. Seventy-two publications underwent separate assessments; 71 remained eligible after adjudication. Five procedural domains were classified by information nature, provenance and access. Descriptive analyses separated physical measurements from observational evidence and examined specialty patterns and sensitivity to evidence definitions. Among 71 publications, 50 (70.4%) described capabilities and 36 (50.7%) reported measured, observed or recalled results. Physical measurements or device-displayed quantities had identified acquisition routes in seven (9.9%), decreasing to five (7.0%) when two boundary evidence types were set aside; five further publications had unclear routes. Direct observations or clinical records contributed results in 26 publications. Four reported temporal curves. Data-availability statements occurred in 38 publications (53.5%); 25 of these offered access on request. Excluding qualitative event-absence evidence reduced reporting to 29/71 (40.8%). Submitted domain-state agreement among all 72 assessed publications was 88.3%; a descriptive check after entry correction yielded 94.2%. Procedural reporting should connect each capability or result to its acquisition source, evidence location and resource-specific access conditions. The distinction between physical measurements, clinical observations and qualitative event absence is central to interpreting robotic performance. A concise core with modality-specific fields could help investigators document these links in protocols, case-report forms and publications. Prospective evaluation should assess consistency, completion burden and whether the record helps readers locate and interpret supporting resources. PROSPERO registration: CRD420261486023.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Che et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: