Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Traffic homicides involving drunk driving, excessive speed or illegal street racing expose the difficult boundary between conscious negligence and dolus eventualis, a distinction that determines the applicable penalty and the jurisdiction of the Jury Court. This research examines which criteria make it possible to distinguish dolus eventualis from conscious negligence in traffic homicides, and what impacts this distinction has on the driver’s criminal liability. The general objective is to identify the elements that justify classifying a traffic death as negligent or intentional. As specific objectives, the first chapter examines the legislative development of traffic crimes and the increased severity introduced by the reforms of the Brazilian Traffic Code; the second analyzes the dogmatic and criminal-policy foundations of traffic-related liability, with emphasis on the objective duty of care, objective imputation and the principle of trust; and the third compares the doctrinal and case-law criteria used to distinguish both concepts. The methodology adopts a qualitative approach, based on bibliographic, documentary and case-law research, examining the Brazilian Penal Code, the Brazilian Traffic Code and its amendments, and decisions of the Superior Court of Justice and the Federal Supreme Court. The theoretical framework draws mainly on Zaffaroni and Pierangeli (2021), regarding the limits of criminal policy; Roxin (1997), regarding objective imputation; and Bitencourt (2024), regarding the distinction between dolus eventualis and conscious negligence. The findings indicate that intoxication, excessive speed or the seriousness of the accident alone are not sufficient to establish dolus eventualis; the evidence as a whole must show that the driver persisted despite the concrete possibility of causing death. The study concludes that the distinction must rest on objective and verifiable circumstances, with sufficient reasoning to avoid both an unjustified expansion of dolus eventualis and an unduly lenient treatment of conduct in which the assumption of risk is demonstrated.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Santos et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: