Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Background Outcome-Based Education (OBE) organizes curricula around measurable graduate outcomes, yet critical scholarship warns that outcomes frameworks tend to narrow toward what is easiest to specify and assess. This study develops a Technical-Reflective-Adaptive (TRA) competence model intended to strengthen, not replace, OBE in economics teacher education. Methods A two-phase qualitative design was used. Phase 1 applied a model-building approach, integrating critical curriculum theory, constructive alignment theory, graduate employability scholarship, and sustainability competence frameworks. Phase 2 used an illustrative single case, an Indonesian Economics Education program, to check the premises of the model. Item-level summaries of two audio-recorded lecturer interviews, shared with a companion study, were analyzed thematically and translated into design requirements. Results Four case patterns informed the model: a complete outcome chain on paper that was applied unevenly at course level, with final grades often not reported per course outcome; competence understood mainly in technical terms and OBE equated with project work, with no reference to reflection; assessment dependent on individual course plans without an institutional attainment system; and adaptive outcomes, such as entrepreneurship and internships, present but loosely tied to graduate outcomes. Each pattern was traced to a design requirement. On this basis the TRA model specifies three competence dimensions, five design principles (tri-dimensional backward design, course-level alignment audit across dimensions, mandatory authentic and reflective assessment, experiential learning paired with reflection, and a continuous quality improvement loop), and a curriculum architecture compatible with Indonesian OBE instruments. Conclusions The model converts the critique of outcome reduction into an auditable design requirement. Because the case evidence is small and preliminary, the model is a theoretically grounded proposal that requires validation through expert review, pilot implementation, and longitudinal study.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Amalia et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: