Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This article asks how the adoption of input-intensive farming practices is associated with changes in institutions of collective action in Indigenous farming communities in northern Chile, including reciprocal labor, communal work, irrigation governance, and coordinated responses to pest spillovers. It also examines how out-migration, aging, and absentee landholding shape the resident social base through which these obligations are enacted. Drawing on a multi-site qualitative study of focus groups conducted in the valleys of Azapa, Camarones, and Codpa, three territories with contrasting levels of input-intensive farming and market integration, we examine how farmers describe changing production conditions, collective obligations, and recurring coordination problems. Cross-territorial differences in collective action are not explained by production conditions alone; they are also associated with the standards through which farmers judge good farming. In Azapa, where input-intensive farming is most extensive, good farming is judged through productivity, uniformity, and market performance, and interdependent problems such as pest spillovers are more readily reframed as private responsibilities. In Codpa, farming legitimacy remains tied to ecological care, inherited practice, and territorial stewardship, even as out-migration and absentee landholding strain collective coordination. Camarones occupies an intermediate position in which productivist and stewardship standards coexist and remain contested. The adoption of input-intensive farming practices is thus associated with differentiated trajectories of institutional weakening, hybridity, and continuity under strain. The sustainability of Indigenous agri-food systems depends in part on whether interdependent agrarian problems continue to be recognized as shared responsibilities or are privatized as the moral perimeter of good farming narrows.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Bravo-Peña et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: