Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Food Policy Groups (FPGs) are increasingly positioned in the literature as vehicles for advancing more just and participatory food system governance. However, how their members actually experience procedural justice remains underexplored. By adopting an interpretive approach, this paper aims to develop a nuanced, contextually-grounded understanding of how procedural justice is perceived in practice. To this end, this study performs a comparative analysis of two FPGs: a UK Food Partnership embedded within a county council structure and a US Food Policy Council situated within a county government. By examining how participants across different stakeholder positions perceive procedural justice within contrasting governance structures, the paper moves beyond abstract theorizations toward empirically grounded analysis of how justice perceptions are made and unmade through the ordinary workings of food system governance. The analysis identifies four process variables that shape whether participatory food system governance generates experienced procedural justice: the quality of facilitation, the alignment between formal structures and actual practice, the temporal dynamics of trust-building, and the organizational cultures within which participatory mechanisms operate. More broadly, we advance the concept of a formalization paradox, demonstrating that formal democratic mechanisms can obscure (rather than enable) procedurally just processes. In doing so, the paper complicates assumptions about the relationship between democratic design of participatory food system governance and procedurally just processes. Instead, we argue that procedural justice is fundamentally relational and processual, produced through the everyday practices of governance, rather than through structural arrangements alone.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Parzonko et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: