Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Discards represent a significant but often poorly quantified component of fishing mortality in tuna and tuna-like fisheries. Reliable, fleet-wide estimates separating dead discards from live releases are needed as inputs to stock assessments. Discard estimation studies typically focus on one or a few species of particular interest, and the relative performance of alternative estimators has rarely been assessed across the full species assemblage taken by a fleet. Here we describe and apply a ratio-based framework to estimate discards from different species for the Portuguese pelagic longline fleet in the Atlantic Ocean, using at-sea observer data raised to total fleet effort derived from logbook and Vessel Monitoring Systems (VMS) records. Species-specific discard rates were estimated by area and quarter with hierarchical fallback for data-limited strata, converted to biomass using length–weight relationships, and split into dead-discard and live-release components using at-haulback mortality. Uncertainty was quantified by a trip-level bootstrap, accounting for the clustering of sets within observer trips. Predictive performance was assessed by trip-level cross-validation and compared against a model-based negative binomial generalized linear mixed model (NB GLMM) fitted to the same data, with and without a year term. The two approaches performed comparably when given the same information, with no consistent advantage to either. Comparison against an electronic logbook census for blue shark indicated under-prediction of approximately 18%, present across the full range of reported catch and most pronounced in areas with low observer coverage. Repeating that comparison with the model-based estimator gave a similar under-prediction with larger stratum-level error. The estimated discard biomass was dominated by large-bodied, fully-discarded sharks under retention prohibitions, including the bigeye thresher and more recently the shortfin mako. The main target species, swordfish and blue shark, also have some annual discards, either due to minimum size regulations, depredation events or fleet and market preferences. The approach offers a practical and transferable basis for discard estimation of different species in pelagic longline fisheries operating under tuna-RFMO mandates.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Coelho et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: