Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
From male deep-sea squid attaching spermatophores to other males to jewel beetles mating with beer bottles, animals are often observed directing behaviour towards targets or stimuli that, at first glance, may appear ‘incorrect’ or ‘inappropriate’. Such misdirected behaviours, broadly defined as behaviours directed towards targets other than those for which they likely evolved, have attracted researchers' attention for centuries. The persistence of misdirected behaviours, combined with their seemingly maladaptive nature, has often led them to be viewed as mistakes, anomalies or paradoxes. In this review, we make a case for rethinking how misdirected behaviours are studied. In particular, we highlight the behavioural filters framework as a way to reframe the study of misdirected behaviour. Under this framework, which draws on concepts introduced by signal detection theory, individual animals have a hypothetical filter through which targets are perceived. The breadth of this filter varies from broad to narrow and determines the range of targets that will elicit a given behaviour. Individuals with broad filters will engage in seemingly misdirected behaviours, such as mating with heterospecifics, members of the same sex or inanimate objects, whereas individuals with the narrowest filters will only ever direct behaviour towards the most appropriate targets. We discuss how the filters framework can link different forms of misdirected behaviour and focus attention on the internal and external conditions that influence when and why animals engage in it, including in the face of anthropogenic environmental change. Rather than viewing misdirected behaviours as mistakes, which limits our understanding of their evolution, a more productive approach is to consider them as a consequence of context-specific flexibility in animal behaviour.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Richardson et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: