Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Survey identifies current preferences for prostheses and willingness to randomize patients among surgeons.
OBJECTIVES Many models of bioprosthesis are available for pulmonary valve replacement in adults with congenital heart disease but there is a lack of randomized evidence to guide practice. We surveyed congenital cardiac surgeons to establish current practice and willingness to change within a clinical trial. METHODS An online survey was sent to all consultant congenital cardiac surgeons in adult congenital centres in UK and Ireland. Information was sought on preferred prostheses, factors influencing decision-making, implant technique, postoperative anticoagulation, practice variations in adolescents, and willingness to randomise patients to different prostheses within a trial. RESULTS Responses were obtained from 27 (69%) surgeons. 19 (70%) preferred an Edwards bovine pericardial valve, most commonly the Inspiris Resilia (7, 26%). Only 2 (7%) favoured the Hancock II valve, the remaining 6 (22%) preferred pulmonary homografts. Data regarding long-term freedom from reintervention (23, 85%) was the most important factor influencing prosthesis choice. 22 (81%) surgeons were willing to randomise adult patients to either a bovine pericardial valve or porcine xenograft in a clinical trial, with Perimount Magna Ease and Hancock II the most acceptable, respectively. Willingness to randomise dropped to 11 (41%) surgeons for adolescent patients. CONCLUSIONS This survey demonstrates heterogeneity in the choice of pulmonary valve prosthesis. Combined with a lack of evidence from clinical trials, our findings support the presence of clinical equipoise. Most surgeons are willing to change practice suggesting that a pragmatic, multicentre, randomized controlled trial comparing bovine pericardial versus porcine xenograft for pulmonary valve replacement in adults is feasible.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Bond et al. (2025) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: