Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Background Emergency Departments faced amplified pressures during COVID, with Procedural sedation (PS) demands on clinical spaces and PPE use. Queen Alexandra Hospital, Portsmouth, tested intra-articular haematoma blocks (IAHB) as an alternative to PS for manipulating closed ankle fracture dislocations. Method Between October 2020 and April 2021, patients with displaced ankle fractures received IAHB using 10ml of 1% lignocaine. Data collected comprised pain scores, time from first x-ray to reduction, and acceptability of the reduction. A retrospective analysis compared this with patients who underwent PS for ankle fractures between March and August 2020. Results 25 patients received IAHB and 28 received PS . Time from the first x-ray to manipulation was faster with IAHB (65.9 min) compared to PS (82.9 min). In the IAHB group, six had unsatisfactory first attempts, of which five had a second manipulation, with three being successful. One required manipulation under anaesthesia, and another had an unsuccessful PS followed by fixation. In the PS group, five had unsatisfactory reductions. One underwent multiple PS attempts before fixation, and four others required external or open reduction. The number of unsuccessful reductions was similar in both groups. Importantly, IAHB demonstrated significant reductions in pain scores with no post-operative infections. The cost analysis revealed a notable difference, with the approximate cost per case being £0.60 for IAHB, compared to £4.50 for procedural sedation. Conclusions IAHB for ankle fractures is effective, safe, and cost-efficient. It negates risks of PS and the need for specific clinical space and skilled personnel for sedation.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Elmesalmi et al. (2024) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: