Key result
The antigen capture polymerase chain reaction (AC-PCR) method detected enteroviruses in 7.6% of water samples compared to 5.1% using traditional cell culture, indicating higher sensitivity.
Observational
No
AC-PCR is a feasible and more sensitive method than traditional cell culture for detecting enteroviruses in concentrated recreational waters.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
AC-PCR may improve enterovirus detection in recreational waters; leaves open whether it should replace cell culture in routine monitoring.
The water quality of Lake Orta was evaluated for recreational use. This lake was the only Italian lake to undergo a ‘liming treatment’ which neutralizes water acidity by adding carbonates. Chemical, bacteriological and virological parameters were monitored for 3 years after the treatment ended. Chemical and bacteriological studies were performed according to national standard methods (DPR 470/82) whereas F′ specific bacteriophage were enumerated according to an international standard (ISO 10705–1). Enteroviruses were detected by the observation of a cytophatic effect on buffalo green monkey cultures. Also, the possibility of applying molecular biological techniques for enterovirus detection directly to waters concentrated without previous isolation of viruses in cell culture was verified. The sensitivity, specificity and feasibility of both methods were evaluated. The association between the direct detection of enteroviruses and the indirect indication of their presence by the presence of bacteriophages, and the relationship between bacteriophage presence and bacteriological contamination were also evaluated. In the course of surveillance, none of the samples infringed the law with respect to the physical–chemical parameter (pH < 6). As far as bacteriological characteristics were concerned, 16.6% of the samples taken in 1993 infringed the law, as well as 19.4% of samples in 1994 and 19.4% in 1995. The level of faecal coliforms most frequently exceeded the given limits. The detection test for enteroviruses was positive in 5.1% of the samples using the traditional method with cell culture, and it was positive in 7.6% using the antigen capture polymerase chain reaction (AC‐PCR) method directly applied to concentrated waters, indicating the feasibility and a higher sensitivity of the AC‐PCR method compared to cell culture. Bacteriophages were present in all the samples that were positive in the virological analysis, as well as in 46.7% of negative samples.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Maiello et al. (1999) conducted an observational in Water quality and enterovirus contamination. Antigen capture polymerase chain reaction (AC-PCR) vs. Traditional method with cell culture was evaluated on Detection of enteroviruses. The antigen capture polymerase chain reaction (AC-PCR) method detected enteroviruses in 7.6% of water samples compared to 5.1% using traditional cell culture, indicating higher sensitivity.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: