Key result
Pressure half-time underestimates MVA compared to planimetry by ~0.19 cm2 per higher MR grade.
Why the study?
To evaluate how concomitant mitral regurgitation assessed qualitatively and quantitatively influences mitral valve area calculations by pressure half time compared to planimetry in rheumatic heart disease.
Does concomitant mitral regurgitation affect the accuracy of mitral valve area calculation by pressure half time compared to planimetry in patients with chronic rheumatic heart disease?
Observational (n=72)
Does concomitant mitral regurgitation affect the accuracy of mitral valve area calculation by pressure half time compared to planimetry in patients with chronic rheumatic heart disease?
The pressure half-time method significantly underestimates mitral valve area in patients with rheumatic mitral stenosis and concomitant mitral regurgitation, highlighting the need for direct planimetry measurements in these patients.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Pressure half-time may underestimate mitral valve area with concomitant regurgitation; leaves open optimal measurement strategy in rheumatic mitral stenosis.
AimsAim was to study how concomitant mitral regurgitation (MR) assessed by qualitative and quantitative methods influence mitral valve area (MVA) calculations by the pressure half time method (MVAPHT) compared to reference MVA (planimetry) in patients with rheumatic heart disease.Methods and resultsIn 72 patients with chronic rheumatic heart disease, MVAPHT was calculated as 220 divided by the pressure half time of the mitral early inflow Doppler spectrum. Direct measurement by planimetry was used as reference MVA and was mean (SD) 0.99 (0.69–1.99) cm2. Concomitant MR was present in 82%. MR severity was assessed qualitatively in all, semi-quantitatively by measuring the vena contracta width in 58 (81%), and quantitatively by calculation of the regurgitant volume in 28 (39%).MVA was significantly underestimated by MVAPHT, with increasing MR. In regression analyses MVAPHT underestimated MVA by 0.19 cm2 per higher grade of MR severity in qualitative assessment, and by 0.12–0.13 cm2 per mm larger vena contracta width and 10 ml larger regurgitant volume, respectively. The presented associations were more evident when i) MR severity was quantified compared to qualitative assessment and ii) reference measurements were made by three-dimensional transoesophageal recordings compared to transthoracic recordings.ConclusionMVAPHT underestimated mitral valve area compared to planimetry in patients with MS and concomitant MR. This study highlights the importance of taking the MR severity into account when evaluating MVA based on the PHT method. Direct measurements should be included in clinical decision making.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Hauge et al. (2023) conducted an observational in chronic rheumatic heart disease (n=72). Mitral valve area calculation by pressure half time method (MVAPHT) vs. Reference MVA (planimetry) was evaluated on Mitral valve area (MVA) calculation (Underestimation by 0.19 cm2 per higher grade of MR severity). Mitral valve area calculation by pressure half time significantly underestimated MVA compared to planimetry, with underestimation increasing by 0.19 cm2 per higher grade of mitral regurgitation.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: