Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
In the latter part of the 20th century, Drs Jeremy Swan and William Ganz introduced the use of balloon-tipped, flow-directed catheters, and the modern era of right heart catheterization (RHC) began. It remains the "gold standard" for diagnosis and management of a wide spectrum of cardiopulmonary diseases, and accordingly, the techniques of the procedure have continued to evolve into the 21st century. This review will discuss the modern practice of RHC, including best practices in procedure technique, updated hemodynamic definitions of disease states, and recent developments in the interpretation of provocative maneuvers.RHC may be performed to confirm a diagnosis of pulmonary hypertension (PH) when its presence has been suggested by noninvasive imaging or clinical suspicion. Hemodynamic evaluation is critical to properly phenotype PH patients, and this information is crucial before initiation of pulmonary vasodilator therapy. RHC is also standard in those being considered for advanced heart failure (HF) therapies. In the most recent mechanical sup port and cardiac transplant guidelines, RHC has a class 1 indication to include measurement of the pulmonary vascular resistance (PVR). Pre–heart transplant candidates should undergo RHC every 3 to 6 months, especially if reversible PH is present or HF symptoms are worsening.1,2 This screening may be omitted in stable patients with a left ventricular assist device who had no evidence of PH before implant.3The routine use of pulmonary artery (PA) catheter-guided therapy in patients admitted with HF and symptomatic congestion has failed to reduce hospital length of stay or mortality and may increase adverse events.4 Therefore, RHC should only be performed in those whose hemodynamics are unclear. A commonly encountered clinical situation is that of worsening renal function while attempting diuresis, a situation in which knowing filling pressures and cardiac output (CO) can guide medical therapy or the need to initiate inotropic or mechanical support.Preparation is the key to success. Even before entering the catheterization lab, the operator should have a suspicion of what will be found on the hemodynamic evaluation. Do the findings fit the clinical scenario? For example, if a 26-year-old woman without risk factors for left heart disease, normal left atrial (LA) size, a severely dilated right ventricle (RV) with D-shaped septum, and an estimated RV systolic pressure of 100 mm Hg is found to have a significantly elevated PA wedge pressure (PAWP), the measurement accuracy should be questioned (and confirmed). Issues with patient positioning, calibration, leveling, zeroing, and measurement technique can all contribute to these errors.Whenever possible, RHC should be performed in stable, noncritical patients who are able to lay supine with their legs flat. Operators should have an unobstructed view of hemodynamic monitors, real-time electrocardiogram, and waveforms. Pressure measurements should be recorded during spontaneous breathing without breath-hold maneuvers, which can lead to inadvertent Valsalva and pre-load alteration. To avoid altered breathing patterns associated with sedation, use of topical and subcutaneous local anesthetics is favored over intravenous sedation. If premedication is required for particularly anxious patients, oral conscious sedation should be considered.The pressure transducer should be zeroed to atmospheric pressure at the level of the LA. To help ascertain LA position using external landmarks, Kovacs et al. retrospectively compared commonly cited anatomic landmarks to computed tomography–derived biatrial levels. They found that the right atrium (RA) was one-third of the thoracic diameter posterior to the anterior thorax surface in 98.5% of patients. The LA was located in the midthorax level (halfway between the anterior sternum and the table surface, ie, midchest) in 97.4% of patients. Deviations from these points can significantly alter the number of patients classified as having PH and elevated LV pressure.5 Therefore, it is advisable to use a measuring stick to accurately place the transducer at the midthoracic level as an estimation of the LA location.In addition to inspecting the waveform to determine the current location of the catheter, operators should examine the pressure tracing quality, looking for signs of overdampening or underdampening (see Figures 1A and 1B). Overdampening can occur when air is introduced into the catheter or tubing and may result in the loss of a dicrotic notch in the PA tracing, a blunted RV end-diastolic inflection point, or reduction in the overall amplitude of the pressure tracing (Figure 1A) with concurrent decrease in measured systolic pressure and increase in diastolic pressure (therefore, the mean pressure is usually not affected).6 This can be addressed by fastidiously flushing the catheter or tubing. Catheter ringing (underdampening; Figure 1B) may occur when the frequency of the transmitted waveform (heart rate) approximates the natural resonance frequency of the transducer system and falsely increases the amplitude of the resultant waveform. Similar to overdampening, mean pressure is usually not affected.6 Ringing may be exacerbated by microbubbles in the system; therefore, flushing the system or the introduction of a denser fluid, such as blood or contrast, into the catheter to alter the resonant frequency of the system may reduce this artifact.7 Reducing the length of tubing between the transducer and the fluid-filled catheter may also ameliorate catheter ringing. Pressure lines and transducers should always be inspected for bubbles, which should be removed via adequate flushing before beginning.Antecubital or internal jugular venous access under ultrasound guidance is generally preferred and associated with a better safety profile. Once the venous sheath has been placed, we recommend documenting an oxygen saturation from the high superior vena cava. This allows for an immediate assessment of perfusion status and, importantly, will be compared to the PA saturation to rule out left-to-right intracardiac shunting. A significant step up in oxygenation should prompt further investigation. With the balloon inflated, the PA catheter is then advanced into the RA. A typical RA pressure (RAP) tracing is shown in Figure 2A, consisting of a and v waves with x and y descents.During RAP assessment, the presence or absence of the Kussmaul sign should be documented (Figure 2B). This paradoxical increase in pressure (or failure to fall) during inspiration is indicative of a noncompliant RV and can be seen in constrictive pericarditis and advanced HF, including dilated, ischemic, or restrictive cardiomyopathies. In a single-center study, the Kussmaul sign was found in 43% of patients referred for transplantation and was associated with worse hemodynamics, echocardiographic parameters, higher natriuretic peptide levels, higher diuretic doses, lower sodium levels, and worse clinical outcomes.8 The RAP tracing may show prominenty descents, in which the downward slope is more prominent than that of the x wave and the nadir usually deeper (Figure 2B). This suggests a less distensible RV from a variety of causes. Recent work by Harada et al. suggests that this finding, in combination with elevated RV systolic pressure, may predict worse outcomes in HF patients with preserved ejection fraction (HFpEF).9A step up in systolic pressure occurs with advancement of the catheter into the RV (Figure 2C). Occasionally, a square root (or dip-and-plateau) sign may be present, which can be seen with severe tricuspid regurgitation, pericardial constriction, and restrictive physiology.10 As the catheter passes the pulmonic valve and enters the PA, a step up in diastolic pressure and a characteristic dicrotic notch in the downslope of the PA tracing are seen (Figure 2D). Finally, when the catheter is advanced into the distal PA, pressure will fall as the catheter achieves a wedge position (Figures 2E and 2F). The PAWP tracing is achieved when a static column of blood is created between the occlusive balloon, the distal pulmonary arterial and venous vasculature, and the LA. The PAWP serves as a surrogate for LA pressure and—in the absence of mitral stenosis—LV end diastolic pressure (LVEDP).Because of the diagnostic and therapeutic implications of the PAWP, it is of paramount importance to measure it in a standardized fashion with regard to the respiratory and cardiac cycle. In most situations, pressure measurements should be recorded at end expiration, when intrathoracic pressure closely approximates 0 and has the least impact on intracardiac pressures.11 In some situations, particularly severe lung disease or morbid obesity, large respiratory pressure variation may be present, and intrathoracic pressure at end expiration may be higher than 0. Esophageal pressure–transducing balloon catheters can be used to estimate intrathoracic pressure, thus allowing for more exact determination of intracardiac pressures by subtracting the esophageal pressure.12 As these instruments are not routinely available, reporting an average pressure over the respiratory cycle may be preferred.13 We typically report both end expiratory and averaged values when significant respiratory variation is present. Additionally, Cheyne-Stokes breathing may be present in patients referred for RHC. Operators should be careful to measure all pressures during the same phase of the breath cycle (hyperpnea versus apnea).Recent work has also highlighted the importance of standardization of PAWP measurement with regard to the cardiac cycle. At end diastole, the mitral valve is open, and thus LA pressure (and PAWP) should be equal to LVEDP. On the PAWP tracing, end diastole occurs just before the c-wave (mitral valve closure). Because the c-wave may be difficult to identify on a fluid-filled catheter tracing, the peak and trough of the a-wave is averaged and correlates with the pre–c-wave value (Figure 2E). This value is the best estimate of LVEDP. Because no a-wave exists when atrial fibrillation is present, end-diastolic PAWP is measured 130 to160 milliseconds after the onset of QRS and before the v-wave.11,14,15 Mean PAWP, or PAWP averaged over the cardiac cycle, encompasses the pressure waveform during both systole and diastole. This may best represent the pressure "felt" by the pulmonary circulation from the left heart. Although in many instances mean PAWP approximates end-expiratory PAWP, the presence of large v-waves and atrial fibrillation lead to a mean PAWP greater than end-diastolic PAWP (Figure 2F). The use of mean PAWP rather than end-diastolic PAWP contributes to the phenomenon of "negative" diastolic pulmonary gradients.16–18 The presence of large v-waves suggests a contribution of left heart disease (significant mitral regurgitation or stiff LA syndrome) regardless of the measured PAWP and should always be noted as part of the hemodynamic report. Frequently, large v-waves resolve during systemic vasodilator challenge.Whenever a PAWP tracing is atypical or if a diagnosis of PH is being considered and measured PAWP is greater than 15 mm Hg, a PAWP saturation should be obtained to confirm complete occlusion and an accurate measurement.11 An inadequately wedged balloon allows the transduction of higher pressure from the more proximal PA into the wedge tracing, falsely elevating it. It also allows leakage of deoxygenated blood into the static column distal to the balloon. To obtain a wedge saturation, slowly withdraw and waste a sample of blood from the distal port of the PA catheter with the balloon inflated in wedge position until the blood appears bright red, then withdraw another 1- to 2-mL sample for oxygen saturation measurement. A truly wedged catheter should yield an oxygen saturation reflective of the postcapillary pulmonary bed, typically >90% or within 5% of systemic oxygen saturation. Lower values should prompt repeat attempts to wedge or consideration of a direct LVEDP measurement.The direct Fick method remains the "gold standard" for estimating CO. However, the technique requires specialized equipment to properly measure oxygen consumption, which is generally not feasible in most catheterization laboratories. Therefore, thermodilution (TD) and the indirect Fick method are more commonly used. The indirect Fick method uses estimated values for oxygen uptake originally derived from the TD method in patient populations that were highly selected, lean, and homogeneous with regards to age and race. Therefore, extrapolating oxygen consumption to a population of patients with HF, PH, or obesity is likely to induce error.19When measuring TD CO, injection of saline should occur at the same point of the respiratory cycle.20 Although TD is commonly cited to be less accurate in the setting of tricuspid regurgitation and extremes of CO, studies have shown good correlation with TD and Fick in these situations.21,22 TD is the preferred method of measuring CO,23 with one caveat being the presence of an intracardiac shunt, in which TD should not be used. An analysis of over 15 000 patients undergoing RHC showed a poor correlation between TD and indirect Fick methods, with one-third of the cohort differing by greater than 20%. Low cardiac index as measured by the TD method was superior in predicting 90-day mortality to the Fick method; therefore, TD should be favored in clinical practice.24 This was recently corroborated in a cohort of pulmonary arterial hypertension (PAH) patients in which the TD and indirect Fick indices (with oxygen consumption estimated by 3 different formulas) were compared against direct Fick indices. The TD method and indirect Fick using the Dehmer formula had high accuracy (but poor precision) as compared to direct Fick, whereas indirect Fick using the Bergstra or La-Farge-Miettinen methods overestimated and underestimated oxygen consumption, respectively. Also notable in this study was the lack of effect of tricuspid regurgitation, even when severe, on TD accuracy.25The current hemodynamic definition of PH is a mean PA pressure (mPAP) >20 mm Hg.26 Additional hemodynamic classification is based on the PAWP, with >15 mm Hg considered consistent with Group 2 PH, or PH due to left heart disease (PH-LHD). PH-LHD encompasses a spectrum of widely varying pathologies and clinical diagnoses, including HF with reduced (HFrEF) or preserved ejection fraction (HFpEF), valvular disease, restrictive cardiomyopathy or constrictive pericarditis, and congenital or acquired cardiovascular conditions associated with left-to-right shunting.PH-LHD can be further dichotomized into isolated postcapillary PH (IpcPH)—in which elevated PA pressure is a result of (and proportional to) the degree of chronic passive elevation of LV filling pressure—and combined postcapillary and precapillary PH (CpcPH), in which PA pressure is often higher than expected ("out of proportion") to the degree of LV filling pressure.How to define the precapillary component remains debated. The Fifth World Symposium on Pulmonary Hypertension (WSPH) proposed that the diastolic pressure gradient (DPG) alone should differentiate these 2 entities (with DPG < 7 mm Hg in IpcPH and ≥7 mm Hg in CpcPH), but subsequent controversy over its prognostic ability and concerns related to measurement fidelity led to its abandonment in favor of PVR in the Sixth WSPH position statement. Thus, IpcPH is currently defined as PAWP > 15, mPAP > 20 mm Hg, and PVR < 3 Wood units (WU), and CpcPH is defined as PAWP > 15, mPAP > 20 mm Hg, and PVR ≥ 3 WU.11 Because the use of PAH-specific therapies is not recommended in the CpcPH population, this differentiation is more relevant for risk stratification, assessment of candidacy for advanced HF therapies, and clinical trial enrollment rather than to specifically guide treatment.Other hemodynamic parameters useful in risk stratification are shown in Table 1.In the early stages of cardiopulmonary disease, resting pressures may be normal, with abnormalities in hemodynamics only becoming apparent with provocation.27 Diuretics may also lower LV filling pressures into the normal range despite the presence of LHD. This practice can make PH-LHD in the setting of HFpEF particularly difficult to differentiate from PAH. Therefore, saline loading or dynamic exercise can be important additional tools in the evaluation of undifferentiated dyspnea. These provocative maneuvers may unmask occult PH-LHD, differentiate PAH from HFpEF, or diagnose exercise PH (EPH). Vasodilator challenges can be performed to assess reactivity of the pulmonary in patients with Group 1 PAH or Group 2 PH as part of cardiac transplant candidacy undergoing RHC are in a and many have to the Therefore, resting PAWP can be normal even in the setting of and lead to an In a cohort of patients as were to occult PH-LHD when normal resting PAWP to >15 mm Hg after an of of saline over to However, one of this study is that a in PAWP to >15 mm Hg with saline can be seen even in as suggested by et and In their study of and PAWP to >15 mm Hg, but a PAWP mm Hg after of normal further a of mm Hg as an to saline loading from et who 7 of saline and of the cohort into a cohort of patients referred for RHC. The found that of those with precapillary PH and of those with no PH at were as postcapillary derived from of the in and precapillary PH patients mm Hg as an to saline loading (see Figure et al. recently the of both saline loading to and exercise during the same procedure in a cohort of and HFpEF patients. With saline had a mean PAWP of 7 mm Hg and to a mean of 6 mm Hg less than mm while patients with HFpEF had a mean PAWP of mm Hg which to mm Hg with a PAWP > mm Hg after a saline over is likely and may be consistent with are for these we are likely including in PAH clinical RHC is more to and than resting hemodynamic in intrathoracic pressure are and end-expiratory pressure may be an Because of it is recommended to the average pressure over respiratory during exercise increases catheter ringing and which are to the and of waveforms. Therefore, only the mean of the for and PAWP are typically is another important It may be performed or operators exercise symptoms more is and is more significant in the position compared with However, may also be more difficult to requires additional equipment and and may not always be Thus, it is important to the impact of on hemodynamic At an patient will have a lower PAWP, and CO, and a higher heart and oxygen as compared with a supine With these and at are likely no The PAWP increases with in supine or typically supine PAWP is mm Hg higher than exercise a supine patient will have a reduction in to be due to the of pulmonary in 3 when in supine PVR also in but as the resting PVR is generally higher than the in exercise PVR is more of exercise is also but may have pulmonary vascular to increases in CO, as by early increase in PA pressure and PAWP that may within of In a cohort of et al. that with the mean PAWP of mm Hg significantly to mm Hg at 2 but to mm Hg by 7 significantly higher than With continued exercise to a higher the PAWP to 20 mm Hg at 2 and to 15 mm Hg by 7 Therefore, even patients may routinely 20 mm Hg early in but within The most recent position from the while 3 to is to oxygen for a of 2 is with an exercise of consumption for Fick estimation of exercise be measured and be derived from standard as is with indirect Fick at the of during an exercise the TD method is a and should be However, from et al. as TD may significantly the obtained via the direct Fick method versus at peak The lower TD led to significant of when to 2 most recent position not identify a widely hemodynamic definition of A of mPAP > mm Hg was at the as it was that the pulmonary to exercise on and no value to define This was by a large of patients the age of mPAP during the of normal for those was mm Hg, but was mm Hg for those of patients achieved an mPAP > mm Hg with pressure is a that may be elevated due to high in the absence of Therefore, more recently proposed for have on the slope et al. suggested that the normal of pulmonary resistance are between and mm and that a slope of this at points of to a diagnosis of et al. recently showed reduced cardiovascular with normal resting but who this during et al. a in a cohort of patients of normal those with pulmonary vascular disease, and those with all with a resting mPAP 20 mm In the normal the of exercise PAWP and mPAP were and mm Hg, and a had mPAP > mm The diagnostic accuracy of resting and exercise and was resting hemodynamic parameters had diagnostic but exercise and mPAP had high diagnostic accuracy at values of and mm Hg, respectively. As seen in Figure using lines at these the were able to be from the 2 Finally, the noted that the combined were at (CO) in most patients, if an mPAP > mm Hg is before is the can be even at having the 2 studies have suggested the method of mPAP > mm Hg and > 3 is more than the slope an PAWP to exercise have been debated. The position suggests that a PAWP of 20 or mm Hg may be considered the of normal, but also points out that evidence these is et al. showed in a cohort of patients, no 20 to had PAWP > mm Hg at peak but of those to this to the with the of a PAWP and the of the wedge pressure have also been In a cohort of patients of HFpEF patients, and those with but normal PAWP and et al. found that PAWP with CO, with the slope in the and the in the HFpEF versus mm a slope of 2 mm was defined as standard the of the patients with normal PAWP and normal were found to have importantly, these patients were found to have a higher risk for cardiovascular HF or subsequent RHC with PAWP ≥ 15 mm In the et al. cohort of patients, were mm with both and et al. a cohort of patients consisting of with normal ejection no PH, and oxygen consumption due to in the of filling pressures during exercise with normal this cohort had lower peak exercise RAP and PAWP compared with normal in lower and as a of exercise of the cohort had evidence of The this and suggested that the diagnosis should be considered when exercise RAP is mm Hg, PAWP is mm Hg, or when the increase in RAP is mm Hg or PAWP increase is mm Hg, particularly when of output have not been should be that of an RV gradient may occur during In a cohort of patients without congenital heart disease, et al. a mean gradient of mm Hg at and mm Hg with were more commonly found in with higher peak oxygen work showed that a high gradient was not associated with HF but in the lower filling higher CO, and higher peak oxygen that these patients were referred for it is at present of an gradient with exercise can be a normal or is This may also have important implications for using as a diagnostic saline loading and exercise increase venous to the saline loading has on blood pressure and heart as compared with exercise and thus ventricular as the being exercise is more and on the such as heart with diastolic filling and with resultant and oxygen may be more than saline loading for the of occult exercise may a more accurate of it requires more specialized equipment and is less difficult to requires less and specialized and is more widely As exercise more respiratory variation and thus a higher of in waveform For these the Sixth WSPH has recommended that patients with to high of PH-LHD and PAWP to 15 mm Hg undergo a over exercise should be performed in with or PAH. This is typically performed with at to may also be including intravenous or or A is defined as a decrease in mPAP ≥ mm Hg to an value mm Hg with or CO. It is not recommended in of as a is not associated with a to the presence of has been associated with in a cohort of PH patients regardless of and therefore, a may be considered for prognostic is typically not in PH-LHD, it is being performed in the of heart transplantation evaluation. transplant candidates with a PVR > and gradient >15 mm Hg are at higher risk of early However, if PVR can be reduced to while a systolic pressure of mm Hg, risk appears is the most commonly used and has the safety of a may increase LA pressure and pulmonary intravenous intravenous and have also been used to for Although only when PA systolic pressure is mm Hg, a recent study by et al. found that elevated PVR in those with mPAP < mm Hg had Therefore, we recommend in with PVR > 3 regardless of PA hemodynamics are critical for diagnosis and of cardiopulmonary The modern era has seen in the standardization of techniques and waveform maneuvers are being used to diagnosis and assess for early
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Bonno et al. (2020) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: