Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The 2012 Zurich Consensus Statement 1 recommends a graduated protocol for return to play following concussion, beginning with rest and followed by increasing levels of physical activity. With the growing recognition that both physical and mental exertion can aggravate concussion symptoms 2, 3 and perhaps prolong recovery 4, 5, the Zurich statement also highlights the importance of cognitive rest and the need to limit exertion with activities of daily living that may exacerbate symptoms. In children and adolescents, this would include the modification of school attendance and activities to avoid provocation of symptoms. Thus, it is important to consider developing principles and guidance for resuming academic activities after concussion. Research on the academic effects of concussion has generally shown no adverse long-term outcomes 6, 7. In most cases, concussion symptoms and cognitive difficulties will improve in a matter of days 8. However, problems can persist for weeks or months, causing significant academic disruption. There are limited empirical data specifically addressing the academic effects of concussion. Medical professionals who diagnose and treat concussion will often make recommendations to a student's school so as to try to reduce symptoms and foster optimal recovery. A number of authors have developed recommendations for academic re-entry and accommodations after concussion 4, 9-14 and the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention offers ‘Heads Up for Schools’ materials with concussion information and practical guidance (http://www.cdc.gov/concussion/HeadsUp/schools.html). There is emerging consensus on the optimal process for return to school, but still a lack of research. Teachers and other school staff are ultimately responsible for implementing any recommendations, and for ensuring that the recovering student's needs are considered and addressed. We propose the following principles and practical guidance, in the hope that this will stimulate discussion and encourage empirical study of best practices. There are several graduated return to learn protocols in the literature that are analogous to the Zurich graduated return to play protocol. The Oregon Center for Applied Science has a six step protocol with two home steps and four school steps 15. Halstead et al. 14 recommend that a student stay home from school until able to tolerate 30–45 min of cognitive activity, at which point a gradual return to school is suggested. Master et al. propose a six step plan that includes: a prescription for physical and cognitive rest, a gradual reintroduction of cognitive activity, homework at home before schoolwork at school, school re-entry, gradual reintegration into school and full return to school. They introduce the concept of subsymptom threshold for cognitive activity and the strategy of pacing, or gradually increasing cognitive activity while staying below the student's symptom threshold 9. In this article, we build on their plan and attempt to integrate aspects of other return to learn approaches. While a standard graduated protocol may work well for return to play, as students return to learn after a concussion a more flexible approach may be needed for each individual student. We summarise relevant background literature in Data S1. We propose principles based on this background literature. These principles are meant to help inform the adjustment of an individual student to his/her particular school environment. We then present an initial approach to be further developed and refined and discuss the emerging consensus on return to learn. As can be seen in Data S1, the current literature is suggestive of a complex and dynamic set of injury mechanisms at work in the brain after concussion associated with a window of dysfunction and increased vulnerability. In the context of sports, there has been a heightened focus on minimising the risk of more severe injury and symptoms by removing the athlete from play until recovery is complete. However, in the academic context, removing students from school until they are recovered is not practical. In this sense, the pressure to keep going in school after concussion may actually be greater than the pressure to return to play. There is growing attention to the academic effects of concussion in the literature and emerging agreement on some guiding principles for return to learn. A step by step plan for return to learn has advantages in providing a consistent yet flexible approach for parents, health professionals and school personnel that could be adopted across various schools. Unfortunately, this approach could also lead to fitting an individual student into each step rather than using the guidelines as a starting point to develop an individualised plan for facilitating a particular student's return to school. Alternatives to the limitations of a linear step by step approach are available in the literature 10, 11, 14, 16. Principles for return to learn can integrate these approaches and contribute to developing an individualised plan for a particular student's recovery from concussion. Tables 1–3 and additional discussion of Table 1 are included in Data S2. Table 1 proposes three phases (ABC) for return to learn. Progression through these phases involves a gradual increase in activity while attempting to remain below the student's ‘symptom threshold’. This threshold is based on the length of time and the intensity of cognitive activity, other activity and environmental stimulation that results in an exacerbation of symptoms 9, 17. ‘Pacing’ of activity can include rest breaks at home or in school before the student reaches a symptom threshold (e.g. a rest break could be built into the students schedule for 5–15 min every 30–45 min, or at home a rest break at 80% of the time it takes for symptom exacerbation). Use of the SCAT3 (http://bjsm.bmj.com/content/47/5/259.full.pdf) or Child SCAT3 (ages 5–12; http://bjsm.bmj.com/content/47/5/263.full.pdf) Symptom Evaluation, or another symptom scale, is recommended as a way to monitor symptoms 1. A form such as that included in the REAP guidelines (http://www.rockymountainhospitalforchildren.com/sports-medicine/concussion-management/reap-guidelines.htm) can be sent to school with the student. Most students recovering from concussion will immediately benefit from a core group of accommodations, listed in Table 2. As time goes on, accommodations can (and should) be adjusted more to fit the individual student's needs. Table 3 presents examples of typical symptoms during each phase and more specific examples of physical, cognitive and academic activities, as well as academic accommodations that may be useful with these symptoms. A ‘symptom wheel’ approach may be helpful in tailoring accommodations to fit the student's needs http://www.nasponline.org/publications/cq/40/6/return-to-learning.aspx. The REAP guidelines (Reduce-Educate-Accommodate-Pace) for returning to school after concussion noted above reflect the above literature and emphasise the importance of teamwork among parents, school athletic and academic professionals and medical professionals. Additional guidance for return to learn is available in the literature 9, 18. The purpose of the phase ABC approach presented in Table 1 is to propose general principles, to be further developed in the literature, for implementing a consistent yet flexible approach to returning individual students to school after a concussion. It must be emphasised again that this approach is aimed primarily at those students who will have a typical recovery from concussion in 1–2 weeks. When symptoms are more severe or prolonged, return to learn recommendations are best developed in the context of an individualised and comprehensive management plan put together by concussion specialists in conjunction with the school team. Also, while early intervention and reassurance can help to optimise recovery, over-reacting may sometimes be problematic, too, such as ‘cocooning’ a child or keeping children out of school longer than necessary. One of the most challenging aspects of managing the return to school after concussion is the dynamic and variable nature of the symptoms and of recovery. This can be quite vexing to students, parents and teachers trying to figure out what kinds of supports are needed and for how long. Regular meetings between parents and school staff will help in making adjustments to the return to learn plan as recovery progresses and also help to avoid either over- or under-serving the student. Middle and high school students can be included in these meetings as well. A Case Example presented in Data S3 may help to illustrate some of these issues. There is a rapidly growing knowledge base on concussion, particularly regarding what is now understood to be multiple injury pathways and recovery trajectories. While resolution of symptoms is most often complete within 2 weeks, recovery can take longer, especially in children and adolescents. There is growing attention to return to learn but no consensus yet or accepted guidelines. We have proposed a set of principles, a graduated return to learn protocol, and a set of core academic accommodations that is informed by the broader concussion literature as well as the work of others who have written on this topic. The evidence base remains limited in this area but the time may be ripe for an organisation such as the National Collaborative on Children's Brain Injury, which is comprised of leading paediatric brain injury experts from medical and academic communities, to form a consensus for return to learn after concussion. Data S1. Background literature. Data S2. Tables 1–3 and Discussion. Data S3. Case example. Please note: The publisher is not responsible for the content or functionality of any supporting information supplied by the authors. Any queries (other than missing content) should be directed to the corresponding author for the article. We thank the following organisations for financial support: The Robert Rich Family Foundation, Program for Understanding Childhood Concussion and Stroke, Buffalo Bills (Ralph Wilson) Team Physician Fund and the Buffalo Sabres Foundation. The authors report no known conflicts of interest.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Baker et al. (2014) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: