Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Analyzing the problem of elites in Robert Dahl’s “politology” presents significant difficulties. In addition to the various approaches and interpretations of the political elites presented in his books and articles, one has to take into account their many interpretations, which at the moment are almost impossible to reduce to a single denominator. The study of elites in the works of R. Dahl covers more than half a century. If we imagine it in the form of a kind of theoretical continuum, then at one extreme point there will be examples of elite analytics from the standpoint of “pure science”, at the other point there will be ideas and interpretations with a touch of normativity and even quite clearly expressed value orientations. In his early works of the 1950–1960s, given the problematic nature of defining the concept of “ruling elite”, the American scientist preferred to formulate it in purely hypothetical terms. But by the beginning of the 21st century in the book On Political Equality (2006), Dahl’s analysis of the problem of the political elite as a privileged stratum in a democratic society acquires a clearly expressed value coloring. In his work Dilemmas of Pluralistic Democracy: Autonomy vs Control (1982), R. Dahl specifically focuses on the theoretically complex solution to the issue of interaction between the principles of hierarchy and organizational independence. Dahl’s main line of argument was that in large political systems, independent organizations help prevent domination and create mutual control. The main alternative to mutual control in government is hierarchy. Managing a system as large as an entire country solely through hierarchy reinforces the dominant positions of political groups that control the process of government. Independent organizations help curb hierarchy and dominance. Empirically, R. Dahl’s theoretical position was largely based on experimental data collected by him in his early work Who Governs? Democracy and Power in an American City (1961). The R. Dahl’s interpretation of the role of elites and the prospects for the evolution of the political system has long been considered classical and in fact occupied a dominant position not only in American, but also in Western European university political science. The theoretical and empirical research carried out by R. Dahl made a significant contribution to the debate between “pluralists” and the so-called “elitists,” which continued until the 1980s. and largely determined the specific “practicality” of North American political science. The results of these studies were initially accepted even by such outstanding political theorists as W.E. Connolly and G. Sartori. However, later both theorists began to take a more restrained position. One of the main reasons for such restraint is the widespread growth of scientific and philosophical skepticism regarding R. Dahl’s pluralistic concept. This is evidenced by many recent works devoted to the problem of degradation of political elites in Western countries. However, in recent years there has also been a rather sharp theoretical turn, represented in a series of attempts to use the methodology developed by R. Dahl in the direction of synthesizing the theory of political elites with various versions of the theory of civil society.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Владимир Гуторов (2023) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: