Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
AbstractWithin the literature on conflict resolution and peace-building, there is a growing awareness about the need to move beyond 'minimalist' (absence of war) and 'maximalist' (absence of different types of structural violence) notions of peace. While the first concept is too narrow—it conceals much human suffering and does not take into account the root causes of armed conflict—the latter is too inclusive, open-ended and difficult to measure. There is, despite this growing consciousness, a lack of midterm definitions of peace that can help peacemakers assess whether a peace process is on the right track, say 10 or 15 years after a civil war has been terminated. In fact, when operationalising and empirically measuring how 'peaceful' post-civil war societies are, many scholars continue to employ indicators based on minimalist or maximalist visions of peace. In this article we introduce the concept of 'legitimate peace', which we argue can function as a midterm benchmark for peacemakers, and outline the benefits associated with its use. AcknowledgementsThe authors are extremely grateful to Kristine Höglund, Anna Jarstad, Roland Kostić, Mimmi Söderberg Kovacs, Lotta Themnér, Peter Wallensteen and the editors and external reviewers at Conflict, Security & Development for their extremely helpful comments and suggestions. We are also thankful for the economic support provided by Riksbankens Jubileumsfond and the Swedish International Development Cooperation Agency.Notes 1. Inspiration for the terms minimalist and maximalist visions of peace comes from CitationCall and Cousens, 'Ending Wars and Building Peace'. 2. 'Midterm' is here used in reference to situations where post-civil war societies have, militarily speaking, stabilised and there is no longer an overt risk for renewed, large-scale violence, but many of the underlying, structural deficiencies that caused the original war are still in place. Midterm should therefore foremost be seen in substantive, rather than temporal terms (even if we can assume that this type of peace will not appear during the first few years of a peace process). Exactly when this midterm will arrive will therefore differ depending on the local circumstances. 3. For some of the central works on peace-building see e.g. CitationBarnett, 'Building a Republican Peace'; CitationCall, 'Knowing Peace When You See It'; CitationCall and Cousens, 'Ending Wars and Building Peace'; CitationChandler, 'The Uncritical Critique'; CitationCockell, 'Conceptualizing Peacebuilding'; CitationDayton and Kriesberg, Conflict Transformation and Peacebuilding; CitationDoyle and Sambanis, 'International Peacebuilding'; CitationDoyle and Sambanis, Making War and Building Peace; CitationDuffield, Development, Security and Unending War; CitationFortna, Does Peacekeeping Work; CitationParis, At War's End; CitationParis and Sisk, The Dilemmas of Statebuilding; CitationRichmond, The Transformation of Peace; CitationRichmond, Peace in International Relations; and CitationStedman et al., Ending Civil Wars. 4.CitationBarnett, 'Building a Republican Peace'; CitationCall, 'Knowing Peace When You See It'; CitationKahler, 'Statebuilding after Afghanistan'; and CitationDoyle and Sambanis, Making War and Building Peace. 5.CitationHolsti, The State, War, 84, 87. 6. For further information on top-down processes of nation-building see e.g. CitationAnderson, Imagined Communities; and CitationDeutsch, Nationalism and Social Communication. For a good overview of the debate on nation-building see CitationÖzkirimli, Theories on Nationalism. 7. For a good overview of the various processes of identity formation, see CitationSmith, 'The Ethnic Sources'; and Özkilirmili, Theories on Nationalism. 8. See e.g. CitationHöglund and Söderberg Kovacs, 'Beyond the Absence'; and CitationStedman et al., Ending Civil Wars. 9. For more information on this, see the sections 'Minimalist conceptions of peace' and 'Maximalist conceptions of peace' below.10. Important exceptions are CitationBarnett, 'Building a Republican Peace'; CitationCall, 'Knowing Peace When You See It'; CitationKahler, 'Statebuilding after Afghanistan'; and CitationDoyle and Sambanis, Making War and Building Peace. For more information on this see 'Midterm conceptualisations of peace' below.11.CitationMiall et al., Contemporary Conflict Resolution, 42–44.12.CitationRichmond, Peace in International Relations, 47, 99–101.13.CitationMac Ginty, No War, No Peace, 156. It is important to note that even if there were few peacekeeping operations that intervened in states plagued by civil wars during the Cold War, there were many examples of other types of interventions. It was, for instance, common that the Soviet Union and USA provided secondary support (weapons, training, troops, military intelligence, etc.) to governments and rebel movements throughout the Third World.14.CitationHampson, Nurturing Peace; and CitationStedman and Rothchild, 'Peace Operations'.15.CitationStedman et al., Ending Civil Wars, 1–4.16.CitationBoutros-Ghali, 'An Agenda for Peace', 11.17. See e.g. CitationHartzell and Hoddie, 'Institutionalizing Peace'; and CitationJarstad and Nilsson, 'From Words to Deeds'.18. See e.g. CitationThemnér, Violence in Post-Conflict Societies.19. See e.g. CitationHartzell et al., 'Stabilizing the Peace'; and CitationJohnson, 'Partitioning to Peace'.20. See e.g. CitationHartzell et al., 'Stabilizing the Peace'.21. See e.g. CitationFortna, Does Peacekeeping Work.22.CitationStedman et al., Ending Civil Wars, 49.23. See e.g. CitationBrancati and Snyder, 'Time to Kill'; CitationCollier et al., 'Post-Conflict Risks'; and CitationFortna, Does Peacekeeping Work.24. The quote is taken from CitationWoodward, 'Economic Priorities', 184.25.CitationMac Ginty, No War, No Peace, 114–15; and CitationMac Ginty, 'Post-Accord Crime', 115.26.CitationHöglund and Söderberg Kovacs, 'Beyond the Absence'.27.CitationMac Ginty, No War, No Peace, 95.28.CitationRegan and Norton, 'Greed, Grievance, and Mobilization'; and CitationSambanis, 'A Review of Recent Advances'.29. A good example of this is the low-level insurgency in Casamance (Senegal). For more information, see CitationDeets, 'Bitter Boots'.30.CitationMac Ginty, No War, No Peace, 125; CitationMac Ginty 'Post-Accord Crime', 110; and CitationHöglund and Söderberg-Kovacs, 'Beyond the Absence', 381.31.CitationMac Ginty, 'Post-Accord Crime', 101.32.CitationOlsson, Gender Equality.33.CitationOhlson, Power Politics and Peace Policies; and CitationWalter, 'The Critical Barrier'.34. Originally formulated by CitationSchmid, 'Peace Research and Politics'. Quote taken from CitationMiall et al., Contemporary Conflict Resolution, 44.35.CitationSchmid, 'Peace Research and Politics'.36.CitationGaltung, 'An Editorial'; CitationGaltung, 'Violence, Peace, and Peace Research'; and CitationMiall et al., Contemporary Conflict Resolution, 15, 43–44.37.CitationRichmond, The Transformation of Peace, 36, 157.38.CitationRichmond, Peace in International Relations, 36.39.CitationCall, 'Knowing Peace When You See It', 181.40.CitationParis, At War's End, 3–4; and CitationBarnett, 'Building a Republican Peace', 88.41. See e.g. CitationCockell, 'Conceptualizing Peacebuilding'; CitationMiall et al., Contemporary Conflict Resolution, 56–57; and CitationParis, At War's End.42.CitationParis, At War's End, 57.43. See e.g. CitationConteh-Morgan, 'Peacebuilding and Human Security'; CitationParis, 'Human Security'; and CitationRichmond, 'Emancipatory Forms of Human Security'.44.CitationBuzan et al., Security.45. See e.g. CitationMac Ginty, No War, No Peace; CitationRichards, No Peace No War; CitationRichmond, The Transformation of Peace; and Richmond, Peace in International Relations.46. See e.g. CitationChandler, 'The Uncritical Critique'; and CitationDuffield, Development, Security and Unending War.47.CitationMac Ginty, No War, No Peace.48. Ibid., 24.49.CitationRichmond, Peace in International Relations, 109.50. In both years the life expectancy in the Republic of Congo was approximately 54 years. World Bank, Life Expectancy at Birth, Total (Years). Available at: http://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SP.DYN.LE00.IN/countries/CG?display = graph [Accessed 30 May 2011].51.CitationSartori, 'Concept Misformation', 1035.52.CitationSchmid, 'Peace Research and Politics', 223.53.CitationRichmond, Peace in International Relations, 13.54. Many of these scholars are working within what is sometimes referred to as the literature on 'state-building'. For a good overview of this literature, see CitationKrasner, 'Sharing Sovereignity'; and CitationParis and Sisk, The Dilemmas of Statebuilding.55.CitationCall, 'Knowing Peace When You See It', 173. Similar thoughts have been developed by Call and Cousens, 'Ending Wars and Building Peace'.56.CitationBarnett, 'Building a Republican Peace'.57.CitationKahler, 'Statebuilding after Afghanistan'.58. Ibid., 299.59.CitationDoyle and Sambanis, Making War and Building Peace.60. Ibid., 18, 73.61.CitationHolsti, The State, War.62. Ibid., 82–83.63. Ibdi., 84.64. Ibid., 85.65. Ibid., 87.66.CitationTajfel, 'Social Identity'.67.CitationGurr, Peoples Versus States.68. For further information on top-down processes of nation-building see endnote 6.69. For further information on the various processes of identity formation, see endnote 7.70. An example of the latter is the development of pan-Arabism during the 1950s and 1960s in much of the Middle East. One of the movement's aims was to create a common identity that would unite Muslim and Christian Arabs.71.CitationDarity Jr., International Encyclopedia, 565.72.CitationKnack and Keefer, 'Does Social Capital Have an Economi Payoff?'; and CitationThemnér, Violence in Post-Conflict Societies, 167.73.CitationPutnam, Making Democracy Work.74. By 'Western liberal bias' we simply mean the tendency of many policy-makers, and some scholars, to equate 'midterm' visions of peace with the presence of formal, democratic institutions that are commonly found in Western Europe and North America.75.CitationRichards, No Peace No War.76. See CitationKostić, 'Nationbuilding as an Instrument of Peace?'.77.CitationHolsti, The State, War, 90–91.78. See e.g. CitationGurr, Peoples Versus States; CitationMuggah, No Refuge; Themnér, Violence in Post-Conflict Societies; and CitationUrdal, 'A Clash of Generations?'.79. In several war-ridden and post-civil war societies, issues regarding which ethnic groups belong to the 'demos' is a major source of tension. This is, for instance, true concerning both Mandingos in Liberia and Banyamulenge in the Democratic Republic of Congo.80. Which ethnic groups should be allowed to own land is also an important source of conflict in many war-affected countries. This is, for instance, true concerning Mandingos in Liberia.81. In some Muslim countries that have experienced armed civil strife, such as Algeria and Egypt, a central source of contention is if Islamist movements should be allowed to form political parties that participate in the electoral process.82.CitationBuzan, People, States & Fear; and CitationHolsti, The State, War, 82–84.83. See e.g. CitationGurr, Peoples Versus States; CitationKostić, 'Nationbuilding as an Instrument of Peace?'; and CitationLyons, Demilitarizing Politics.84. See e.g. CitationBerdal, 'Disarmament and Demobilisation'; CitationKostić, 'Nationbuilding as an Instrument of Peace?'; and CitationStedman, 'Spoiler Problems'.85. See e.g. CitationCrocker et al., Taming Intractable Conflicts; and CitationHolsti, The State, War.86. See e.g. CitationStedman et al., Ending Civil Wars.87. See e.g. CitationBolongaita, 'Controlling Corruption'; and CitationNilsson, Reintegrating Ex-Combatants.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Themnér et al. (2014) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: