Key result
Among 105 blood pressure self-measurement devices tested, only 47.6% fulfilled all five validation criteria of the German Hypertension League Quality Seal Protocol.
Why the study?
How accurate are blood pressure self-measurement devices when assessed by the German Hypertension League Quality Seal Protocol compared to conventional Riva-Rocci measurements?
Observational (n=105)
How accurate are blood pressure self-measurement devices when assessed by the German Hypertension League Quality Seal Protocol compared to conventional Riva-Rocci measurements?
Rigorous testing of home blood pressure devices is crucial, as less than half of the tested devices met all accuracy criteria.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Many self-measurement devices may lack accuracy; Level 5 data leaves open whether unvalidated monitors should be avoided in practice.
OBJECTIVE: The German Hypertension League (Deutsche Hochdruckliga) established a program to assess the accuracy and reliability of blood pressure (BP)-measuring devices in 1999 (Quality Seal Protocol). Here, we report on the results of a testing series of 105 devices designed for BP self-measurement. METHODS: The test protocol for the validation of upper-arm, wrist, and finger devices was developed to compare device to conventional Riva-Rocci measurements based on five criteria: mean systolic and mean diastolic differences, their standard deviations, and a point score representing the correlation of systolic and diastolic errors of individual comparisons. The results of this testing are summarized. RESULTS: From 1999 to 2014, a total of 105 BP devices for self-measurement were tested according to the Quality Seal Protocol. Of these, 47.6% fulfilled all five validation criteria, 55.7% of the upper-arm devices (39 of 71) and 32.4% (11 of 34) of the wrist devices. Finger devices were not offered for testing. Forty-four devices (41.9%) failed multiple test criteria of the validation procedure. A subanalysis with 51 devices tested showed that a stricter definition of the passing point score with a limit of at least 55% would slightly increase the consistency with the conventional criteria in comparison with a point score criterion of at least 50%. It was therefore introduced in 2007. CONCLUSION: The results indicate the importance of a rigorous testing of a BP-measuring device used for home BP measurement to prevent patients from making erroneous treatment decisions.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Tholl et al. (2016) conducted an observational in Blood pressure measurement (n=105). Blood pressure self-measurement devices vs. Conventional Riva-Rocci measurements was evaluated on Fulfillment of all five validation criteria. Among 105 blood pressure self-measurement devices tested, only 47.6% fulfilled all five validation criteria of the German Hypertension League Quality Seal Protocol.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: