Key result
Oscillometric blood pressure devices for home use significantly overestimate low and underestimate high blood pressure values compared to standard mercury manometers.
Why the study?
Do oscillometric blood pressure devices for home use accurately measure blood pressure compared to standard mercury manometer measurements?
Observational (n=1,589)
Do oscillometric blood pressure devices for home use accurately measure blood pressure compared to standard mercury manometer measurements?
Oscillometric blood pressure devices for home use show significant deviations from standard measurements, particularly underestimating high blood pressure values, highlighting the need for validation protocols to adequately represent different blood pressure levels.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Caution advised with home oscillometric BP at extremes; leaves open adequacy of current validation protocols across ranges.
Objective: Accuracy of blood pressure (bp) measuring devices for home use must be validated before sale permission. The ‘test seal’ of the German Hypertension League DHL is established since 1999. To analyze significant influences of variables of test persons and types of devices data of 64 device tests performed between 2001 and 2008 were statistically evaluated. Methods: According to the protocol devices for upper arm measurement (ua) are tested in 96 persons. Distribution of the test persons has to be equal for sex, age and bp categories according to the protocol (http://www.hochdruckliga.de/prufsige.htm). Wrist devices (wr) are additionally tested in another 20 persons with diabetes above 56 years of age (116 persons). Three trained testers take 12 sequential bp measurements of each test person, comparing device and control measurement (method: Riva Rocci and Korotkoff with mercury manometer). For statistical calculation more than 39000 bp measurements taken from 1589 test persons out of 23 wr and 41 ua device tests were analysed using SAS version 9.1. Separated for wr and ua devices mean systolic and diastolic bp differences of test and control measurement and their standard deviation were calculated. Statistical analysis examined the influence of different variables on measurement accuracy by descriptive methods and multivariate regression analysis. Results: The reference bp values show the most important and significant impact on the measurement accuracy of wr and ua devices. Oscillometric devices overestimate low and underestimate high bp values (Pearson correlation coefficients ranging from -0.3 to -0.4 for syst/diast bp values). The other co-variables have little clinical relevance. Table 1 shows the expected change of bp measurement differences by typical variation of variables. Conclusions: In comparison to standard bp measurement oscillometric devices for home use show significant deviations with increasing important and clinical relevant underestimation of high syst/diast bp values. Therefore validation protocols have to consider relevant proportions of different bp levels. Other variables of validation protocols are less important.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Tholl et al. (2010) conducted an observational in Blood pressure measurement (n=1,589). Oscillometric blood pressure measuring devices vs. Mercury manometer (Riva Rocci and Korotkoff) was evaluated on Measurement accuracy (mean systolic and diastolic blood pressure differences) (Pearson correlation -0.3 to -0.4). Oscillometric blood pressure devices for home use significantly overestimate low and underestimate high blood pressure values compared to standard mercury manometers.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: