This is the authors' abstract. We don't add key points for this paper.
This study compared the achievement and ability of a group of retained elementary students with that of a group of continually promoted elementary school students. The two samples were matched on the basis of gender, school entry reading achievement, grade, and regular school program. Short-term and long-term comparisons between the groups were made using Grade 1 Edmonton Public Schools’ Reading Comprehension Test scores, Grade 3 and Grade 6 Canadian Cognitive Ability Test (CCAT) scores, and Grade 6 subject matter achievement tests. The author concluded that grade retention was inef- fective for improving achievement and ability. Cet article traite d’une etude qui comparait le rendement et les aptitudes d’un groupe de doubleurs au primaire avec celles d’un groupe d’eleves continuellement promus d’une classe a l’autre, egalement au primaire. Les deux echantillons ont ete apparies en tenant compte du sexe, de l’aptitude a la lecture a l’entree a l’ecole et de la classe; tous les eleves etaient inscrits dans le programme scolaire ordinaire. Des comparaisons a court terme et a long terme ont ete effectuees entre les deux groupes a l’aide du Grade 1 Edmonton Public School’s Comprehension Test, du Grade 3 and Grade 6 Cognitive Ability Test (CCAT) et de divers tests de rendement ayant aux matieres de la 6e annee. L’auteure conclut que le redoublement n’ameliore ni le rendement de l’eleve ni ses aptitudes.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Marilyn Westbury (1994) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: