Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This study was designed to investigate the equivalence reliability between the suggested FITNESSGRAM® muscular strength and endurance test, the 90° push-up (PSU), and alternate FITNESSGRAM® tests of upper-body strength and endurance (i.e., modified pull-up [MPU], flexed-arm hang [FAH], and pull-up [PU]). Children (N = 383) in Grades 3 to 6 were tested over a period of a week. Equivalence reliability for the PSU–MPU comparison was acceptable for boys across ages 8 to 10 (Percentage Agreement [Pa] = .74 to .78, Modified Kappa [Kq] = .48 to .56), with good agreement among boys age 11 (Pa = .86, Kq = .72). Equivalence reliability for girls was unacceptable across all ages (Pa = .54 to .59, Kq = –.04 to .18). Reliability estimates were also acceptable for boys on the PSU–FAH comparison across all ages (Pa = .72 to .80, Kq = .44 to .60). Similar results were not found for girls. Consistency of classification was not demonstrated between PSU–PU for boys ages 10 and 11 years; however, acceptable to good estimates were found for the girls' PSU–PU comparison (Pa = .72 to .82, Kq = .44 to .64) with the exception of girls age 11 (Pa = .67, Kq = .34). Practitioners must recognize that using alternative FITNESSGRAM® strength and endurance items may result in a different healthy fitness zone classification for children than the recommended test, the PSU.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Sherman et al. (2006) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: