Key result
Mimics Medical software yielded higher mean volumetric measurements of extra-cranial carotid artery calcifications compared to 3D-DOCTOR software.
Why the study?
The study aimed to compare two different CBCT software packages, Mimics Medical and 3D-DOCTOR, for volumetric and areal measurements of extra-cranial carotid artery calcifications.
Does Mimics Medical software yield different volume and areal measurements of extra-cranial carotid artery calcifications compared to 3D-DOCTOR software?
Observational (n=44)
No
Does Mimics Medical software yield different volume and areal measurements of extra-cranial carotid artery calcifications compared to 3D-DOCTOR software?
Volumetric and areal measurements of extra-cranial carotid artery calcifications obtained with Mimics Medical software are significantly higher than those obtained with 3D-DOCTOR software.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Software choice affects carotid calcification volume estimates; leaves open standardization needs before clinical or research adoption.
Aim: The present study aimed to compare two different CBCT software packages, Mimics Medical and 3D-DOCTOR, in performing the volume and areal measurements of extra-cranial carotid artery calcifications (ECACs). Material and Methods: A total of 44 scans were evaluated. The calcifications were categorized as unilateral or bilateral. Volumetric and areal measurements of ECACs were done with the two software programs. Intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC) was used to evaluate the intra-observer reliability. The difference in measurements between two software groups was evaluated with the t-test. Results: The ECACs were unilateral in 24 cases and bilateral in 20 cases. There were 25 females and 19 males and the mean age of the sample was 63.31 ± 10.21 years. The overall mean volume obtained with Mimics software was 52.97 ± 48.97 mm3 while that obtained with 3D-DOCTOR software was 39.70 ± 34.40 mm3 (P=0.001). Similarly, significant differences between Mimics (109.55 ± 85.40 mm2) and 3D-DOCTOR (98.99 ± 75.34 mm2) software programs were observed for areal measurements (P=0.001). Conclusion: Although high agreement rates were observed in repeated measurements among two software programs, volumetric and areal measures of the ECACs obtained with Mimics Medical were higher than those obtained with 3D-DOCTOR.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Nagihan Koç (2022) conducted an observational in Extra-cranial carotid artery calcifications (n=44). Mimics Medical software vs. 3D-DOCTOR software was evaluated on Mean volume of extra-cranial carotid artery calcifications (mm3) (p=0.001). Mimics Medical software yielded higher mean volumetric measurements of extra-cranial carotid artery calcifications compared to 3D-DOCTOR software.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: