Key result
The Intervention Selection Toolbox, a mixed-method approach combining care delivery process and outcome analyses, successfully identified a protein-enriched diet for preoperative optimization as the highest-impact intervention for aortic valve disease.
Why the study?
Selecting quality improvement interventions based on outcome measures is complex, and tools to support this selection process are lacking.
The Intervention Selection Toolbox provides a structured, data-driven approach to identify and select quality improvement interventions based on patient-relevant outcomes in hospital care.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
May guide preoperative optimization in aortic valve disease; leaves open prospective validation of the toolbox before practice adoption.
BACKGROUND: Measuring and improving outcomes is a central element of value-based health care. However, selecting improvement interventions based on outcome measures is complex and tools to support the selection process are lacking. The goal was to present strategies for the systematic identification and selection of improvement interventions applied to the case of aortic valve disease and to combine various methods of process and outcome assessment into one integrated approach for quality improvement. METHODS: For this case study a concept-driven mixed-method approach was applied for the identification of improvement intervention clusters including: (1) benchmarking outcomes, (2) data exploration, (3) care delivery process analysis, and (4) monitoring of ongoing improvements. The main outcome measures were long-term survival and 30-day mortality. For the selection of an improvement intervention, the causal relations between the potential improvement interventions and outcome measures were quantified followed by a team selection based on consensus from a multidisciplinary team of professionals. RESULTS: The study resulted in a toolbox: the Intervention Selection Toolbox (IST). The toolbox comprises two phases: (a) identifying potential for improvement, and (b) selecting an effective intervention from the four clusters expected to lead to the desired improvement in outcomes. The improvements identified for the case of aortic valve disease with impact on long-term survival in the context of the studied hospital in 2015 include: anticoagulation policy, increased attention to nutritional status of patients and determining frailty of patients before the treatment decision. CONCLUSIONS: Identifying potential for improvement and carefully selecting improvement interventions based on (clinical) outcome data demands a multifaceted approach. Our toolbox integrates both care delivery process analyses and outcome analyses. The toolbox is recommended for use in hospital care for the selection of high-impact improvement interventions.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Zipfel et al. (2020) studied Aortic valve disease (n=5,689). Intervention Selection Toolbox (IST) was evaluated on Identification and selection of an improvement intervention. The Intervention Selection Toolbox, a mixed-method approach combining care delivery process and outcome analyses, successfully identified a protein-enriched diet for preoperative optimization as the highest-impact intervention for aortic valve disease.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: