Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Preprint discusses AI's impact on publishing roles in academia, suggesting a need for reform in evaluation methods.
This is a preprint of the manuscript: "Why the Paper Cannot Do Both Jobs at Once: A Structural Account of Academic Evaluation in the Age of AI" Abstract:This paper argues that AI-assisted writing does not create a new problem for academic publishing; it exposes an existing one. The academic paper as an institutional object simultaneously performs two distinct functions: certifying a contribution to collective knowledge (Fk), and credentialing the individual capacities of its author (Fc). These functions were bundled in a single artifact not because they are conceptually unified but because of a contingent material constraint—the near-identity of the producer of intellectual content P and the executor of textual output E—which made their separation prohibitively costly. Generative AI shifts this cost structure, making the bundling no longer stable. The paper develops a structural account in three steps. First, it formalizes the dual function and introduces a counterfactual test for distinguishing first-mover contributions from within-conversation contributions. Second, it shows that identity filtering in editorial practice is the same dual-function confusion expressed at the editorial layer, and proposes a sequential two-stage editorial process (blind content evaluation followed by identified compliance review). Third, it argues that the competence-credentialing function (Fc), no longer reliably indexed by publication records, must be reconstructed through evidence streams operating at discrete decision points and structured by cross-disciplinary auditability protocols. The paper itself was produced through substantive collaboration between a human author and a large language model; this condition is addressed reflexively in §7 using the framework developed in the paper. The manuscript has been submitted to a peer-reviewed journal and is currently under review.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Zhendong Wang (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: