Key result
A critical review of Guyton's models suggests that plotting venous return curves with right atrial pressure on the y-axis encourages mistaken ideas about its role as a back pressure.
This review clarifies physiological misconceptions regarding the role of right atrial pressure in determining venous return, emphasizing that it should not be viewed simply as a 'back pressure'.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Questions prevailing views on venous return; leaves open revisions to hemodynamic teaching and models.
A. C. Guyton pioneered major advances in understanding cardiovascular equilibrium. He superimposed venous return curves on cardiac output curves to reveal their intersection at the one level of right atrial pressure (Pra) and flow simultaneously consistent with independent properties of the heart and vasculature. He showed how this point would change with altered properties of the heart (e.g., contractility, sensitivity to preload) and/or of the vasculature (e.g., resistance, total volume). In such graphical representations of negative feedback between two subdivisions of a system, one input/output relationship is necessarily plotted backward, i.e., with the input variable on the y-axis (here, the venous return curve). Unfortunately, this format encourages mistaken ideas about the role of Pra as a "back pressure," such as the assertion that elevating Pra to the level of mean systemic pressure would stop venous return. These concepts are reexamined through review of the original experiments on venous return, presentation of a hypothetical alternative way for obtaining the same data, and analysis of a simple model.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
G. L. Brengelmann (2003) conducted a review in Cardiovascular equilibrium. A critical review of Guyton's models suggests that plotting venous return curves with right atrial pressure on the y-axis encourages mistaken ideas about its role as a back pressure.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: