Key result
Achieved systolic blood pressures >=170 mmHg were associated with a nearly 5-fold increased risk of mortality or ESRD compared to 130-139 mmHg, with both higher and lower pressures demonstrating worsened outcomes.
Why the study?
Medical literature and clinical guidelines had not adequately addressed the ideal blood pressure treatment targets for survival and renal outcomes.
Does achieved blood pressure outside the 130-139/60-79 mmHg range increase the risk of mortality or ESRD in treated hypertensive patients?
Cohort (n=398,419)
Yes
Does achieved blood pressure outside the 130-139/60-79 mmHg range increase the risk of mortality or ESRD in treated hypertensive patients?
In a large cohort of treated hypertensive patients, achieved systolic blood pressures of 130-139 mmHg and diastolic 60-79 mmHg were associated with the lowest risk of mortality and ESRD, with both higher and lower pressures increasing risk.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Captured external expert commentary on this paper, strongest first. Original sources are linked where available.
“Physicians have often emphasized the need to bring a patient's blood pressure down as low as possible for the best outcomes. However, the findings of our study suggest that treating patients with high blood pressure too aggressively may potentially lead to poor health outcomes.”
“When treating patients with hypertension, lower blood pressure is not always better. This study demonstrates that overtreatment of high blood pressure can be dangerous to a patient's health. We need to target an appropriate blood pressure range to better treat hypertensive patients. Importantly, physicians should treat each patient individually and provide a personalized care plan for that person.”
Achieved SBP outside 130-139 mmHg was associated with higher mortality or ESRD risk; leaves open optimal targets pending randomized trials.
Background Medical literature or clinical guidelines have not adequately addressed the ideal blood pressure (BP) treatment targets for survival and renal outcome. Objective To evaluate ranges of treated BP in a large hypertension population and compare risk of mortality and end stage renal disease (ESRD). Methods A retrospective cohort study within the Kaiser Permanente Southern California health system was performed from January 1, 2006 to December 31, 2010. Treated hypertensive individuals age >/=18 years were studied. Cox proportional hazards regression models were used to evaluate the risks (hazard ratios) for mortality and/or ESRD among different BP categories with and without stratification for diabetes mellitus (DM) and older age. Results Among 398,419 treated hypertensive individuals (30% with DM), mortality occurred in 25,182 (6.3%) and ESRD in 4,957 (1.2%). Adjusted HR (95% CI) for composite mortality/ESRD in systolic BPs <110, 110-119, 120-129, 140-149, 150-159, 160-169, and >/=170 compared to 130-139 mmHg were 4.1 (3.8,1.3), 1.8 (1.7,1.9), 1.1 (1.1,1.1), 1.4 (1.4,1.5), 2.3 (2.2,2.5), 3.3 (3.0,3.6), and 4.9 (4.4,5.5) respectively. Diastolic BPs 60-79 mmHg were associated with the lowest risk. The nadir systolic and diastolic BP for the lowest risk was 137 and 71 mmHg respectively. Stratified analyses revealed that the DM population had a similar HR curve but a lower nadir at 131 and 69 mmHg but age >/=70 had a higher nadir (140 and 70 mmHg). Conclusions Both higher and lower treated BPs compared to 130-139 mmHg systolic and 60-79 mmHg diastolic ranges had worsened outcomes. Our study adds to the growing uncertainty about BP treatment targets.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Sim et al. (2014) conducted a cohort in Hypertension (n=398,419). Achieved systolic blood pressure >=170 mmHg vs. Achieved systolic blood pressure 130-139 mmHg was evaluated on Composite of mortality or end-stage renal disease (ESRD) (HR 4.9, 95% CI 4.4-5.5). Achieved systolic blood pressures >=170 mmHg were associated with a nearly 5-fold increased risk of mortality or ESRD compared to 130-139 mmHg, with both higher and lower pressures demonstrating worsened outcomes.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: