Key result
Porcine pericardium demonstrated significantly lower calcification and better hydrodynamics compared to bovine pericardium, suggesting it may be more suitable for right heart transcatheter valves.
Why the study?
Porcine pericardium has been used as an alternative to bovine pericardium for smaller transcatheter heart valve delivery diameters, but differences between the materials have not been fully studied.
Does porcine pericardium offer different microstructural, biochemical, mechanical, and hydrodynamic properties compared to bovine pericardium for transcatheter heart valve leaflets?
Does porcine pericardium offer different microstructural, biochemical, mechanical, and hydrodynamic properties compared to bovine pericardium for transcatheter heart valve leaflets?
Porcine pericardium exhibits distinct biochemical, mechanical, and hydrodynamic properties compared to bovine pericardium, suggesting it may be more suitable for right heart system THVs due to lower calcification and better hydrodynamics at lower cardiac outputs.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Porcine pericardium may suit lower-profile THVs; leaves open whether it matches bovine durability or hemodynamics clinically.
BACKGROUND: In order to obtain the smaller delivery diameter, porcine pericardium had been used as a substitute material of bovine pericardium for the leaflet materials of transcatheter heart valve (THV). However, the differences between them had not been fully studied. Therefore, this study compared the microstructure, biochemical and mechanical properties of two materials and hydrodynamics of THV made by the two materials in detail. METHODS: In this study, firstly, the microstructure of pericardium was analyzed by staining and scanning electron microscope; secondly, the biochemical properties of pericardium after different processes were compared by heat shrinkage temperature test, free amino and carboxyl concentration test, enzyme degradation test, subcutaneous implantation calcification analysis in rats; finally, the mechanical properties were evaluated by uniaxial tensile test before and after the pericardium being crimped, and then, the hydrodynamics of THV was studied according to the ISO5840 standard. RESULTS: Compared with bovine pericardium, after the same process, porcine pericardium showed a looser and tinier fiber bundle, a similar free carboxyl concentration, a lower resistance to enzyme degradation, a significantly lower calcification, bearing capacity and damage after being crimped, a better hydrodynamic and adaption with lower cardiac output and deformation of implantation position. Meanwhile the dehydration process of pericardium almost had preserved all the biochemical advantages of two materials. CONCLUSION: In this study, porcine and bovine pericardium showed some significant differences in biochemical, mechanical properties and hydrodynamics. According to the results, it was presumed that the thinner porcine pericardium might be more suitable for THV of right heart system. Meanwhile, more attention should be taken for the calcification of THV made by the bovine pericardium.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Chang et al. (2021) studied Transcatheter heart valve materials. Porcine pericardium vs. Bovine pericardium was evaluated on Microstructure, biochemical and mechanical properties, and hydrodynamics. Porcine pericardium demonstrated significantly lower calcification and better hydrodynamics compared to bovine pericardium, suggesting it may be more suitable for right heart transcatheter valves.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: