Key result
Paced breathing and paced breathing plus biofeedback increased vagal tone compared to quiet sitting.
Why the study?
Deficient cardiac parasympathetic activity has been hypothesized to underlie some cardiovascular disease, prompting investigation into whether non-respiratory mediated increases in cardiac parasympathetic activity could be induced.
Does vagal tone biofeedback and/or paced breathing increase vagal tone and mitigate cardiovascular reactivity to a cold pressor test in healthy young adults?
RCT (n=39)
Open-label
Randomly assigned
No
Does vagal tone biofeedback and/or paced breathing increase vagal tone and mitigate cardiovascular reactivity to a cold pressor test in healthy young adults?
Paced breathing with or without biofeedback significantly increases vagal tone in healthy young adults, though its ability to mitigate acute stress reactivity remains unclear due to heterogeneous physiological responses to the cold pressor test.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
May boost resting vagal tone; leaves open stress-buffering effects on cardiac reactivity, needing larger trials.
Deficient parasympathetic activity to the heart has been hypothesized to underlie some forms of cardiovascular disease. Consequently, this experiment attempted to induce non- respiratory mediated increases in cardiac parasympathetic activity. Thirty-nine subjects were asked to increase their vagal tone using biofeedback, paced breathing, biofeedback plus paced breathing, or quiet sitting. The cold pressor test was used to examine the relative efficacy of vagal tone increase to mitigate cardiovascular reactivity. Repeated measures ANOVAs and t-tests revealed significant increases in vagal tone for the paced breathing, and biofeedback plus paced breathing groups, relative to controls. However, the quality of these increases could not be tested using the cold pressor test because the test failed to produce homogeneous cardiac reactivity.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Glenn et al. (2020) conducted an RCT in Healthy volunteers (n=39). Vagal tone biofeedback and/or paced breathing vs. Quiet sitting was evaluated on Increase in vagal tone (respiratory sinus arrhythmia) during the second practice session (p=0.032). Paced breathing and paced breathing plus biofeedback increased vagal tone compared to quiet sitting.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: