Key result
A proposed nomenclature categorized 12 FDA-approved perioperative artificial intelligence algorithms into opaque (3), translucent (3), and transparent (6) based on their interpretability to clinicians.
Why the study?
As AI expands in perioperative medicine, clinicians lack standardized terminology to understand model interpretability and communicate effectively with algorithm developers.
A proposed nomenclature (transparent, translucent, opaque) provides a standardized, clinician-friendly way to describe the interpretability of AI/ML algorithms in perioperative medicine.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Clinicians need skills to differentiate perioperative AI algorithms amid inconsistent terms; leaves open standardization and developer collaboration.
As implementation of artificial intelligence grows more prevalent in perioperative medicine, a clinician's ability to distinguish differentiating aspects of these algorithms is critical. There are currently numerous marketing and technical terms to describe these algorithms with little standardization. Additionally, the need to communicate with algorithm developers is paramount to actualize effective and practical implementation. Of particular interest in these discussions is the extent to which the output or predictions of algorithms and tools are understandable by medical practitioners. This work proposes a simple nomenclature that is intelligible to both clinicians and developers for quickly describing the interpretability of model results. There are three high-level categories: transparent, translucent , and opaque . To demonstrate the applicability and utility of this terminology, these terms were applied to the artificial intelligence and machine-learning-based products that have gained Food and Drug Administration approval. During this review and categorization process, 22 algorithms were found with perioperative utility (in a database of 70 total algorithms), and 12 of these had publicly available citations. The primary aim of this work is to establish a common nomenclature that will expedite and simplify descriptions of algorithm requirements from clinicians to developers and explanations of appropriate model use and limitations from developers to clinicians.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Melvin et al. (2022) conducted a review in Artificial Intelligence in Perioperative Medicine (n=12). Artificial Intelligence algorithms was evaluated on Categorization of algorithm interpretability. A proposed nomenclature categorized 12 FDA-approved perioperative artificial intelligence algorithms into opaque (3), translucent (3), and transparent (6) based on their interpretability to clinicians.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: