Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Research on innovation often relies on terms such as radical, disruptive, or incremental to distinguish between different types of innovations. Yet these terms are frequently used as synonyms, and their divergent definitions make consistent empirical operationalisation difficult. Drawing on systematic coding of more than 500 scientific definitions, this study provides a quantitative assessment of the conceptual overlaps and distinctive features of six widely used innovation labels. Using a two-step coding process – open coding of definitional elements followed by dimensional-axial coding – we identify 350 unique definitional attributes, grouped into requirements, features, and effects. Our findings show that the commonly used dimensions of novelty and impact mainly distinguish 'ordinary' from 'exceptional' innovations, but do not suffice to differentiate within the latter group. Substantial definitional overlap exists, particularly in the requirements associated with different innovation types, whereas clearer differences emerge in their features and effects. Two qualitative dimensions enable sharper differentiation: (1) whether novelty relates to invention-oriented, knowledge-based changes or to market- and diffusion-oriented innovation outcomes; and (2) whether effects are competence-enhancing or competence-destroying. These distinctions clarify why labels such as radical, discontinuous, and disruptive innovation are often conflated, and they offer researchers and practitioners a more systematic foundation for concept choice and empirical measurement. Overall, the analysis highlights the complexity and context dependence of innovation terminology and calls for more precise and transparent use of common labels in theoretical and empirical research.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Knüpling et al. (2025) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: