Why the study?
How accurate are ICU physicians' predictions of patient survival and functional outcomes?
How accurate are ICU physicians' predictions of patient survival and functional outcomes?
ICU physicians demonstrate variable accuracy in predicting patient survival and functional outcomes, raising ethical questions about relying on these predictions for treatment decisions.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Caution against relying on ICU physician predictions for decisions; cross-sectional data leaves open whether tools can enhance accuracy.
Physicians' outcome predictions probably influence their treatment decisions in the ICU. The importance and accuracy of these predictions, however, are poorly defined. We asked 20 ICU physicians to rate the importance of 14 factors used for treatment decisions. Expected functional outcome rated highest. However, physicians' predictions of patient outcome, specifically survival and need for professional nursing care 45 days after ICU admission, had variable accuracy. For example, physicians predicted death for only 41% of adults who died, but survival for 87% of adult survivors. Predictions of survivors' need for professional nursing care proved 100% correct for children after heart surgery, but only 58% to 73% correct for other patient groups. These inaccuracies pose an important ethical question: what is the proper role of outcome predictions in ICU decision-making? We believe outcome predictions have an important role when they are proven accurate and used within the bounds of loyalty to the patients and respect for his wishes.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Perkins et al. (1986) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: