Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Different non-invasive methods for assessing arterial compliance are feasible in elderly populations but yield indices that are only modestly correlated with each other.
In this issue of the journal, Lind et al. [1] report on the results obtained by assessing three different indices related to arterial compliance in a large group of elderly subjects, and by comparing the data so obtained with a reference index of cardiovascular risk. Over the years, a number of methods have been proposed to assess arterial compliance (or its reverse, i.e. arterial stiffness) in humans. The growing interest towards such an evaluation is due to the relevant impact that altered compliance has on buffering the vascular consequences of continuous pulse amplitude changes. Several non-invasive approaches have been developed to make this evaluation suitable for a clinical setting [2]. The terms involved in these different calculations and methods are summarized in Table 1[3], and should be referred to the general theory underlying these techniques [4,5]. All available non-invasive methods focus on the quantification of a number of surrogate parameters that are related to the degree of arterial stiffness. Three types of arterial stiffness can be considered: (i) systemic arterial stiffness (formerly explored by the ratio of pulse pressure and stroke volume, and now more and more frequently assessed by methods based on pulse contour analysis; (ii) regional or segmental arterial stiffness [commonly assessed by measuring pulse-wave velocity (PVW)]; and (iii) local arterial stiffness of superficial arteries (measured by echo-tracking techniques) [6]. However, some of the devices or methods used in this field can explore more than one type of arterial stiffness. For this reason, their classification is often based not on the type of arterial stiffness explored, but on their methodological features, with the identification of three main groups of techniques: (i) methods based on the analysis of arterial pressure pulse waveform; (ii) methods based on the quantification of pulse transit time; and (iii) methods based on a direct estimation of arterial stiffness through the assessment of arterial diameter and of the corresponding distending pressure [7]. The derived parameters can often be quantified through use of specific devices now readily available on the market, such as the Complior system, the Sphygmocor System, ultrasound devices assessing PWV or providing ultrasonic echo-tracking of arterial wall movements, and devices based on assessment of pulse transit time through the quantification of the relationship between the onset of electrical ventricular activation on electrocardiogram (ECG) and the diastolic phase in the brachial pulse waveform, as detected by a brachial cuff [7].Table 1: Indices of arterial stiffness/complianceOverall, the methods most commonly employed to measure arterial compliance or distensibility are based on the principle of PWV recording [8]. This parameter is a function of the elastic modulus of the arterial wall, of arterial geometry and of blood density. Its assessment comprises the quantification of both the transit time of the arterial pulse along the arterial segment under evaluation and the distance on the skin between the two recording sites [9]. Other commonly employed methods for the assessment of arterial stiffness are based on the direct quantification of corresponding changes in arterial diameter and in blood pressure, according to the Bramwell–Hill formula [7], assuming that the length of the arterial segment considered is constant. Conversely, methods for local determination of arterial stiffness focus on the measurement of cross-sectional arterial distensibility, through use of a vascular echotracking device. In this context, methods also based on pulse flow detection by means of magnetic resonance imaging have been proposed as non-invasive approaches to obtain an estimate not only of arterial PWV but also of local arterial distensibility. However, this technique still faces a number of methodological problems and, at present, has limited clinical application [10,11]. Assessment of arterial compliance/stiffness through methods based on analysis of the arterial pressure pulse These methods are based on a variety of algorithms for the analysis of the arterial pulse, non-invasively detected. They include: (i) an approach measuring pulsatile arterial pressure at the level of the subclavian artery, through a strain-gauge transducer to track the subclavian pulse, combined with Doppler echocardiography to measure aortic blood velocity and aortic annulus diameter. Arterial pressure and aortic flow velocity recordings are quantified to calculate arterial compliance using an electrical three-element model [12,13]; (ii) a method aimed at assessing proximal ‘capacitive’ compliance and distal ‘oscillatory’ compliance by applying a modified Windkessel model [14] to the arterial pulse waveform recorded at the level of the radial artery by a tonometer calibrated through oscillometric blood pressure readings at the arm level (CR-2000; Research Cardiovascular Profiling System, Eagan, Minnesota, USA) [15]; (iii) a method aimed at assessing the effects of ageing and vasoactive agents on the arterial system through the quantification of the ratio between the amplitude of components detected on the second derivative of the peripheral blood pressure pulse waveform, obtained by finger plethysmography [16,17] (Fukuda Electric Co., Tokyo, Japan); and (iv) the analysis of the peripheral arterial pulse waves, detected by a tonometer, to estimate through an appropriate transfer function the central augmentation index (AI) (SphygmoCor device; PWV Medical, Sydney, Australia) [18]. However, it should be emphasized that the relationship between AI and arterial stiffness is quite complex, with AI being influenced by either arterial wall properties and wave reflection, body height, ventricular vascular coupling and heart rate. Moreover, the transfer function applied to a peripheral pulse to reproduce the central pulse waveform, may not invariably yield reliable results. Assessment of arterial compliance/stiffness through methods based on measurement of pulse transit time The Complior System (Colson, Les Lilas, France) gives an automated measurement of PWV [19,20] for one or two arterial segments simultaneously. The transit time is calculated under visual control, by selecting only high-quality blood pressure waves. Conversely, with the Sphygmocor system, pulse transit time between arterial sites is determined in relation to the R-wave of the ECG, by sequentially recording a proximal and a distal pulse, within a short time interval, by means of a single applanation tonometer (Millar, Houston, Texas, USA). Transit time is obtained from the delays between ECG and both pulses waves (PWV Medical) [21]. Other systems available to assess pulse transit time include: (i) the calculation of the difference between flow pulses recorded simultaneously by continuous Doppler probes from left subclavian artery and abdominal aorta bifurcation; (ii) the Wall Track System (Pie Medical, Maastricht, The Netherlands), which quantifies aortic PWV by echotracking changes in arterial diameter, and by subtracting the delay between a point selected on the ECG signal and the point on the pulse wave corresponding to the 10% increase in arterial diameter [22,23]; and (iii) the QKd system (i.e. a system based on a dedicated software added to the Diasys device for ambulatory blood pressure monitoring) (Novacor, Rueil-Malmaison, France) [24]. Making use of the arm cuff for oscillometric blood pressure measurement and of an ECG lead, transit time is measured as the time between the onset of ventricular electrical activity and the diastolic phase of blood pressure recorded through a brachial cuff. Methods based on direct assessment of arterial compliance/stiffness, through measurement of arterial diameter Among these methods is the assessment of beta index, which quantifies the regional arterial stiffness through the assessment of changes, in pressure (oscillometric measurements by an arm cuff) and in diameter (through a vascular ultrasonic phase-locked echotracking device) [25]. The beta index, reflecting the degree of arterial stiffness, results from the logarithmic transformation of the curvilinear relationship between pressure and diameter. This method has also been applied for the evaluation of the stiffness of thoracic aorta [26], making use of Doppler echocardiography at the site of the suprasternal notch and of blood pressure recordings at the brachial artery level. The systems available to perform these assessments include: (i) the Non Invasive Ultrasound System (NIUS2; Asulab, Marin, Switzerland), a device measuring simultaneously and in a continuous fashion both the radial artery internal diameter and the intima–media thickness (IMT) [27–29]. This is performed by means of a high resolution ultrasonic echotracking device and of a Finapres system measuring blood pressure at the finger level [27,30]. Customized software allows for correction of the time delay between the two sites. The pressure–diameter curve is analysed according to Langewouter's mathematical model [31], yielding estimates of arterial compliance, distensibility and incremental elastic modulus. These measurements are defined as isobaric, either for the actual observed ‘operating’ mean blood pressure level or for an arbitrary point of the blood pressure curve, usually set at 80 or 100 mmHg [32]. (ii) The Wall Track System (Pie Medical), a high resolution vascular echotracking device that measures the internal arterial diameter in diastole and allow its changes followed during the pulsatile cycle. This approach can theoretically be applied to all superficial arteries. The IMT can additionally be calculated from the ultrasound measurements [33]. An applanation tonometer (Millar) [34], positioned at the carotid artery level, is usually employed for blood pressure measurement. The tonometer is commonly calibrated through brachial blood pressure measurements or through automatic calculation using a transfer function processing (Sphygmocor; PWV Medical) [34]. (iii) Transesophageal echocardiography, aimed at measuring the ascending aorta wall thickness and the pulsatile changes in its diameter [35]. The elastic modulus of this segment of the aorta can then be calculated by combining these values with a non-invasive blood pressure measurement obtained at the subclavian artery level [12]. All the above methods have been tested by comparison with other techniques, although no gold standard method is available for local assessment of arterial stiffness. Major confounders in such comparisons are represented by continuous changes in pulsatile flow and beat-by-beat blood pressure, obviously affecting the behaviour of arterial mechanics [36]. In most cases, validation studies based on use of Bland–Altman methods [37] to quantify the comparison between different methods have concluded for an acceptable correspondence between different techniques, with a few exceptions [38,39]. Lind et al. [1] offer an additional contribution in this field. Making use of the population-based Prospective Study of the Vasculature in Uppsala Seniors study, they provide us with a simultaneous testing of the feasibility of three techniques for arterial compliance assessment, in a sample of the general elderly population. In this population, assessment of arterial distensibility by carotid artery ultrasound evaluation (CCA), by pulse-wave analysis focusing on the AI, and by assessment of the stroke volume/pulse pressure (SV/PP) ratio through echocardiography, was successfully implemented in 86, 92 and 77% of the explored sample, respectively. Additionally, Lind et al. [1] investigate the intercorrelation among the parameters provided by these methods as well as their relation with the Framingham cardiovascular risk score. The three indices of arterial compliance were significantly, although not very closely, inter-related (r = 0.19–0.34, P < 0.001 for all), and displayed a significant relation to the Framingham risk score (r = 0.12–0.32, P < 0.01). However, in multiple regression analysis, only CCA distensibility and SV/PP were independently related to coronary risk. Providing information on arterial compliance in a general elderly population is both the strength and the main limitation of their study, insofar as caution is needed in extrapolating the results to other age and ethnic groups. Moreover, the non-invasive indices of compliance employed are not free from limitations compared to traditional compliance measurements. As acknowledged by the authors, a correct definition of compliance should simultaneously consider the measurements of blood pressure, arterial diameter and blood flow, all obtained at the same point, which was not the case for the parameters used in their study. Finally, it remains to be defined whether each of these techniques offers the same information on arterial compliance, and whether such information can be equally used in epidemiologic and in pharmacologic studies. The data provided is nevertheless of interest, and should stimulate additional research in this field as well as further progress in the technology of non-invasive arterial compliance assessment.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Parati et al. (2006) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: