Key points are not available for this paper at this time.
Design
Editorial
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This editorial highlights the ongoing debate and methodological challenges in understanding the role of the exercise pressor reflex in ventilatory control during exercise.
Mechanically and metabolically sensitive group III and IV skeletal muscle afferents are one of the primary neural feedback control mechanisms responsible for the circulatory adjustments to exercise (i.e. the exercise pressor reflex; Fisher, Young, & Fadel, 2015; Kaufman & Forster, 1996; Mueller, Clifford, Crandall, Smith, & Fadel, 2017; Smith, Mitchell, & Garry, 2006). There is a large body of research in humans demonstrating the important role of the exercise pressor reflex, in particular the skeletal muscle metaboreflex, in contributing to the sympathetic nerve activity and blood pressure responses to exercise (Fisher et al., 2015). More importantly, alterations in the metabolic and mechanical components of the exercise pressor reflex have been shown to contribute to neurovascular dysregulation and heightened blood pressure responses during exercise in disease (Smith et al., 2006). What is not as clear is the role of the exercise pressor reflex in the control of ventilation during exercise in health and disease. In the Exchange of Views presented by White & Bruce (2020) and Haouzi (2020), the role of the muscle metaboreflex in contributing to exercise hyperpnoea is debated. The technical aspects of experimental design are discussed, and contributions in isolation versus the integrative response during exercise are deliberated. In this regard, although the ventilatory response to exercise has been well described, a complete understanding of the regulatory mechanisms controlling ventilation during exercise in health and disease remains less clear. However, as noted by White & Bruce (2020), there are many studies in humans and animals that support a role for muscle mechanoreflex and metaboreflex involvement in the ventilatory response to exercise (Fisher et al., 2015; Kaufman & Forster, 1996; Mueller et al., 2017; Smith et al., 2006). Furthermore, a synergistic interaction has been reported between the exercise pressor reflex and the central chemoreflex during exercise (Lam, Greenhough, Nazari, White, & Bruce, 2019; Wan et al., 2020; White & Bruce, 2020). Notably, this interaction might be modifiable by exercise training, identifying a therapeutic strategy for reducing afferent feedback from human skeletal muscle and reducing the augmented cardiovascular and ventilatory responses found during exercise in several disease states (Fisher & White, 1999; Smith et al., 2006). A fair amount of the debate around the involvement of the muscle metaboreflex in ventilatory control revolves around the use of postexercise circulatory occlusion and whether that translates to responses during the exercise bout (Haouzi, 2020). This model, which traps the metabolites within the previously active muscle postexercise, has been used in countless human studies. Dr Haouzi highlights several potential limitations with this model that should not be overlooked, including pain. However, although the subject's pain with this manoeuvre cannot be disregarded, one might argue that exercise itself is painful, particularly for patient populations. Nevertheless, even if such caveats are controlled or minimized, these reflexes do not work in isolation during exercise; therefore, how representative are the isolated muscle metaboreflex responses during postexercise ischaemia compared with those evoked during the exercise bout? This is definitely another important point for consideration. There is no question that studying a reflex in isolation has limitations; however, accounting for redundancy in the integration of cardiorespiratory regulation during exercise likewise has challenges, particularly for interpretation. In short, there are few experimental strategies and/or designs that do not have limitations. All we can do as researchers is to minimize the limitations as best we can and carefully consider them in our interpretation of the data. Interestingly, both viewpoints highlight recent studies in which intrathecal administration of fentanyl, the μ-opioid receptor agonist, in humans is used to block afferent feedback from skeletal muscle at the level of the spinal cord during exercise (Amann et al., 2010; Wan et al., 2020). Although these studies cannot differentiate mechanically and metabolically sensitive afferents, they provide convincing evidence for a role of the exercise pressor reflex in the ventilatory response to exercise in human health and disease. These studies are limited to a few laboratories with the requisite expertise and personnel to perform the technique and will therefore probably not become routine. Nevertheless, they lend strong support to further pursuit of a role for the mechano- and metaboreflexes in contributing to ventilatory responses to exercise regardless of potential limitations and caveats with the techniques available for isolating each component of the reflex. The devastating effects of dyspnoea with exertion in disease conditions warrants more studies, not less. We cannot wait for the perfect technique/study, because it does not exist; instead, it is a compilation of studies from many groups using the best available approaches that will be needed to keep this field moving forward. I appreciate the perspectives put forth in this exchange of views and the importance of carefully considering the limitations of the techniques we use in our studies. There is no doubt we have more to learn to improve our understanding of the complexities in the reflex control of ventilation during exercise in human health and disease. This exchange of views highlights the need for further study in this important area of research, while being cognisant of the nuances involved in the experimental strategies used for overall interpretation. None declared.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Paul J. Fadel (2020) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: