Key points are not available for this paper at this time.
Design
Editorial
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Highlights the importance of synergistic interactions between respiratory control inputs, such as the muscle metaboreflex and chemoreflex, in regulating exercise hyperpnoea in both health and heart failure.
Connections link a sequence of three related research papers. The central article which links the other two papers has been published in Experimental Physiology. In a Connections article, an author (or authors) of the central article outlines its principal novel findings, tracing how they were influenced by the first article and how the central article has contributed to the developments made in the third article. The author(s) may also speculate on the direction of future research in the field. Connections articles aim to set the research in a wide context. Muscular exercise imparts considerable and varying challenges on the human body. We have evolved several rapidly acting control mechanisms that regulate the physiological responses to exercise, with the overall aim of maintaining homeostasis. The characteristic cardiorespiratory response permits an increase in oxygen delivery and carbon dioxide removal from working muscles in proportion to the metabolic demands of the exercise. The control mechanisms that underlie the cardiovascular responses (both central and peripheral haemodynamic) are relatively well understood thanks to an impressive volume of research over the past century and more. In contrast, it has proved a considerable challenge for researchers to unmask the control of the respiratory system (specifically, the hyperpnoea) in exercise. One difficulty for researchers is that ventilation can be regulated voluntarily; hence, the obtrusive and unnatural act of its scientific measurement in a conscious participant, often requiring a mouthpiece and nose clip, can very easily impact the variable of interest. But perhaps the greatest challenge lies in the probable complex nature of its underlying physiological control. Either way, the seeming difficulty in its study might be one reason why the study of exercise ventilatory control has been, in my opinion, less popular than its cardiovascular counterpart; that is, until an apparent resurgence of interest in the 21st century, when research studies (such as recent work from my laboratory, e.g., Lam et al., 2019), have continued to try to shine a light on that mysterious physiological question: how is exercise hyperpnoea controlled? The ventilatory responses associated with exercise occur rapidly and in proportion to metabolic rate, and thereby help to ensure the maintenance of the arterial pH and partial pressures of O2 and CO2. This is a remarkable achievement of the respiratory system considering that its most closely regulated variable (arterial partial pressure of CO2/pH) appears to offer no error signal for arterial or central chemoreceptors to drive reflex hyperpnoea. With this in mind, researchers have focused their attention on other potential blood-borne mechanisms, such as exercise-induced changes in chemoreceptor sensitivity or the effects of other circulating factors (e.g., adrenaline or potassium), and on possible neural mechanisms, such as feedforward control from central command and reflex feedback from thin-fibre skeletal muscle afferents (Bruce et al., 2019). Group III and IV muscle afferent fibres contain metabosensitive and mechanosensitive receptors on their free nerve endings and can provide the CNS with information on the metabolic conditions within working muscle. As a possible control mechanism for the exercise hyperpnoea, this is an attractive theory, because these neural signals might be proportionate to metabolic rate and might account for the immediate elevation in ventilation at exercise onset. Like many others before us, in our recent work (Lam et al., 2019) we used a technique of postexercise circulatory occlusion (PECO) after cycling exercise to isolate the role of muscle metaboreceptive afferents. Here, ischaemia will trap metabolic byproducts in the previously exercised leg muscles and will continue to stimulate muscle metabosensitive receptors (a ‘metaboreflex’). But the cessation of muscle contractions should silence muscle mechanoreceptive afferent feedback and central command mechanisms. In agreement with many other groups, we demonstrated, in young healthy volunteers, that ventilation returns to resting levels during PECO, whereas blood pressure remains elevated until free-flowing conditions return (a ‘pressor reflex’). These findings are consistent with the concept that muscle metaboreceptive afferents are unimportant in exercise ventilatory control but contribute to the normal blood pressure responses associated with exercise (known to be driven via powerful sympathoexcitation). However, in our study we also devised and used a new experimental protocol involving PECO, which took some inspiration from the work of Asmussen and Nielsen (1964). Their study was one of the first attempts to examine the role of skeletal muscle afferent feedback in ventilatory control. These two great scientists used circulatory occlusion of leg muscles during cycling exercise and observed higher elevations of ventilation, heart rate and blood pressure versus free-flowing conditions. These were very encouraging findings, because the authors uncovered a method for trapping the metabolic byproducts of exercise in muscle that amplifies the ventilatory response. However, a limitation of their design was that it was impossible to distinguish whether the elevated cardiorespiratory responses were attributable to: (1) enhanced feedback from muscle metaboreceptors; (2) enhanced feedback from populations of muscle mechanoreceptors whose sensitivity can be enhanced by metabolic stimuli; (3) enhanced central command compensating for the diminished capacity of the ischaemic muscle; or (4) some complex combination. Lam et al. (2019) built upon this concept by designing a procedure to isolate the effects of enhanced metaboreflex activity during exercise. Here, the cardiorespiratory responses to single-legged cycling exercise were recorded with (and without) PECO of the inactive contralateral leg, thereby removing the possible confounding influences of augmented mechanoreceptor feedback or central command. An enhanced exercise hyperpnoea was observed during contralateral leg PECO versus free-flowing conditions, suggesting that muscle metaboreceptive inputs can drive ventilatory responses. These data were consistent with another recent study, in which muscle afferent neurotransmission was inhibited during exercise and resulted in suppression of the cardiorespiratory responses (Amann et al., 2010). Why can opposite conclusions be drawn from experimental procedures that examine the role of muscle afferent feedback during exercise versus after exercise? That is yet to be determined. We do not understand fully how neural projections from muscle afferents are integrated centrally, but it is possible that they require some type of synergistic interaction with other inputs active in exercise, such as central command or feedback from muscle mechanoreceptors or arterial chemoreceptors. This might explain why isolated stimulation (via PECO) results in no ventilatory effect, but enhanced stimulation during normal exercise elevates ventilation. If this were true, and also true of other respiratory control mechanisms, then it might explain why researchers have found it challenging to pinpoint the specific mechanisms underlying exercise hyperpnoea (for further discussion, see Bruce et al., 2019). Asmussen, E., & Nielsen, M. (1964). Experiments on nervous factors controlling respiration and circulation during exercise employing blocking of the blood flow. Acta Physiologica Scandinavica, 60, 103–111. Lam, E., Greenhough, E., Nazari, P., White, M. J., & Bruce, R. M. (2019). Muscle metaboreflex activation increases ventilation and heart rate during dynamic exercise in humans. Experimental Physiology, 104, 1472–1481. Wan, H.-Y., Weavil, J. C., Thurston, T. S., Georgescu, V. P., Hureau, T. J., Bledsoe, A. D., Buys, M. J., Jessop, J. E., Richardson, R. S., & Amann, M. (2020). The exercise pressor reflex and chemoreflex interaction: cardiovascular implications for the exercising human The Journal of Physiology, 598, 2311–2321. Interestingly, in some chronic clinical conditions, such as heart failure, muscle metaboreflex activation alone (e.g., via PECO) can generate ventilatory responses not observed in health and therefore contribute to the hyperventilation and breathlessness associated with the pathology. These findings might suggest some type of abnormality/sensitization in the muscle afferent reflex pathway. However, if synergistic interactions exist between respiratory control inputs, we should not examine the mechanisms in isolation; abnormalities might be reflected in their central integration, and this understanding might lead to new therapies. For example, Machado et al. (2020) assessed the interaction between muscle metaboreflex activation (PECO after cycling exercise) and the carotid chemoreflex in heart failure. They demonstrated a suppressed ventilatory response to PECO during conditions of hyperoxia-induced chemoreceptor inhibition in comparison to conditions of normoxia and tonic chemoreceptor activity. This implies the existence of an interaction between the chemoreflex and metaboreflex that might contribute to the hyperventilation during exercise, and any method of reducing the interaction could, theoretically, lead to tangible benefit for patients. This interesting study (Machado et al., 2020) has continued the recent resurgence of interest in ventilatory control during exercise by examining the possible synergistic interactions between different control pathways. In my opinion, this is a very exciting area of research for both physiologists and clinical scientists. Examination of these types of interactions is no easy task; it will require further novel study designs to isolate carefully and combine different mechanisms and to collect precise measurements; something made ever harder by the inherent variability (noise) in human cardiorespiratory measurement. However, given the wide-ranging implications of the research, I hope that more researchers will contribute and combine ideas (synergistically, no doubt) in this fascinating field.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Richard Bruce (2021) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: