Why the study?
The role and implication of the muscle metaboreflex in exercise hyperpnoea in humans remain uncertain due to limitations and confounding challenges of altering circulation during and after exercise.
Design
Viewpoint
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Methodological limits of circulatory maneuvers constrain metaboreflex inferences; leaves open its role in exercise hyperpnoea.
This viewpoint discusses the limitations and challenges of altering the circulation to and from the exercising and post-exercising muscles as a way to study the role and implication of the muscle metaboreflex in exercise hyperpnoea in humans. The circulatory effects produced by the same manoeuvres and their relevance to our understanding of the regulation of circulation in exercise are not discussed in this paper. How breathing is regulated during a dynamic exercise to produce an increase in alveolar ventilation commensurate to the change in metabolic rate has long puzzled, if not obsessed, some of the most significant respiratory physiologists (Comroe & Schmidt, 1943; Dejours, 1956, 1964; Geppert & Zuntz, 1888; Grodins, 1950; Harrison, Harrison, Calhoun, & Marsh, 1932; Zuntz & Geppert, 1886). The ventilatory response to exercise has a very predictable temporal profile: a constant work rate produces an increase in ventilation that always displays an exponential-like pattern (Whipp & Ward, 1980), with an ∼1 min time constant, following an immediate rise whenever exercise is performed from rest (Dejours, 1959). When exercise stops, ventilation returns to baseline with off-kinetics very similar to the on-transient, with a time course that appears to track the changes in pulmonary gas exchange (Haouzi, 2014). In steady state conditions, arterial blood gases are maintained to resting levels, while a relative hyperventilation is typically observed during heavy exercise (Whipp & Ward, 1980). Whatever the work rate forcing (impulse, sinusoidal, ramp), the resulting ventilatory response can still be anticipated from the response observed during a constant work rate exercise (Whipp, 1981). To explain this apparently simple and predictable temporal profile, the strategy chosen has been to try to identify one by one the potential mechanisms involved. This has led physiologists to develop astute experimental approaches to dissociate the multifarious potential candidates contributing to the control of respiration during exercise (Dejours, 1959). The challenge that became evident as more and more information became available was not to establish the list of realistic mechanisms capable of increasing ventilation during muscular activity. This list was certainly essential to first determine, but the conundrum, which still resists elucidation, has been to determine how these physiological systems, taken in isolation or together, can account for an increase in ventilation that prevents alveolar to rise and alveolar to drop despite a severalfold increase in and (Whipp, 1978; Whipp, 1981). This non-linearity could be explained by a phenomenon of redundancy, degeneracy or hierarchy in the strategy of the responses (Haouzi, 2015). These terms are all hiding our poor understanding of the respiratory control system in vivo. Nevertheless, these properties make it difficult, if not impossible, to infer from the study of one mechanism, considered in isolation, its actual contribution to the overall ventilatory response. The study of the effects of the muscle metaboreflex on breathing is no exception to this rule. Skeletal muscle afferent nerve fibres are traditionally divided into four groups (labelled I–IV) according to their conduction velocity (for review, Kaufman & Forster, 1996). First, the fast very large myelinated fibres (group I and II) were considered to be able to stimulate breathing (Bessou, Dejours, & Laporte, 1959), but are now more viewed as ‘historic’ candidates. Over the past 50 years or so, it is the group III and IV muscle afferent fibres (small myelinated or unmyelinated fibres), rather than group I and II, that have been shown to be able to increase breathing (McCloskey & Mitchell, 1972; Mitchell, Reardon, & McCloskey, 1977). They are now considered as the main group of muscle afferent fibres contributing to exercise hyerpnoea. The natural stimuli of these endings, besides ‘pain’, include (i) the accumulation of ‘metabolic by-products’ (muscle metaboreception) (Kaufman, Hill, Pickar, & Rotto, 1993; Mense, 1996), (ii) the mechanical distortion of their receptive field (mechanoreception) (Kaufman et al., 1993; Mense & Meyer, 1985) including the mechanical distortion produced by vascular structures (Haouzi, Hill, Lewis, & Kaufman, 1999), as well as (iii) an increase in local temperature (Hertel, Howaldt, & Mense, 1976; Mense & Meyer, 1985). Not all fibres respond the same to a given stimulus (Adreani, Hill, & Kaufman, 1997; Kaufman, Hayes, Adreani, & Pickar, 2002), but some populations of endings have been suggested to be polymodal (Mense, 1996). Various experimental approaches have been attempted to tackle their actual involvement in exercise hyperpnoea by dissociating their effects from all the other physiological changes produced by a muscular activity. The latter includes, for instance, the changes in (i) the chemical content of the venous or arterial blood, (ii) the central or peripheral circulation, and (iii) the activity of the central structures controlling locomotion (for recent review, Forster et al., 2012). Experimental approaches have been used to study the muscle metaboreflex in animals, such as injecting chemical agents in the arterial supply of resting or contracting muscles, while measuring its ventilatory effects along with the nerve traffic or by acutely stimulating or blocking the transmission of afferent traffic. These techniques cannot be used as easily in humans (Forster et al., 2012). In addition, data obtained from many of these reduced preparations cannot always be translated to exercising humans. As a consequence, there is no certainty about the actual contribution of the muscle metaboreflex in exercise hyperpnoea. There is no agreement either on the actual mechanism(s) of transduction involved (metabolic vs. mechanical stimuli). In human studies, the search for the role of muscle ‘metaboreceptors’ in breathing control has been largely derived from the effects of vascular occlusion (the literature prior to 2004 can be found in Haouzi, Chenuel, & Huszczuk, 2004; and for new studies, Fukuba et al., 2007; Lam, Greenhough, Nazari, White, & Bruce, 2019). Many original studies tried to look at the effect produced by ischaemic contractions, i.e. during exercise (Asmussen & Nielsen, 1964). Unfortunately, the pain produced by ischaemic contractions certainly creates one major confounding factor, challenging, in turn, the physiological relevance of the ventilatory stimulation observed during such uncomfortable manoeuvres. To overcome this issue, a large number of studies have focused their attention on the recovery period (Dejours, Mithoefer, & Raynaud, 1957; Fukuba et al., 2007; Haouzi et al., 1993; Innes, Solarte, Huszczuk, Whipp, & Wasserman, 1989). But again, although occluding the circulation to and from post-exercising limbs do trap the ‘metabolites’ produced during exercise – and still produced during the post exercising period – this intervention will (i) prevent heat removal; (ii) produce a rapid redistribution of blood volume in the occluded limb towards the higher compliance vascular component (venous system) leading to a drop in pressure in the arterial system and an increase in the venous volume; (iii) create, at best, an unpleasant pressure around the region where the cuff occlusion is applied; (iv) produce a significant discomfort and in some subjects painful sensations almost immediately in the ischaemic left leg(s), an issue even more critical when the occlusion is performed while subjects are still exercising before recovery; (v) reduce cardiac preload and thus pulmonary blood flow along with the rate at which venous ‘metabolites’ are reaching the central circulation; (vi) increase cardiac afterload that can evoke a ‘depressive ventilatory component’ of the arterial baroreflex as blood pressure clearly rises (Huszczuk et al., 1993); (vii) affect the circulatory adjustment towards non-occluded muscles; and (viii) constitute a significant distraction for the subjects. As any of these changes can significantly affect breathing (for more discussion, see Haouzi, 2014), whether the ventilatory stimulation observed during such manoeuvres can be interpreted as the result of the muscle metaboreflex remains open to question. In addition, the traffic from thin muscle afferent fibres is not always increased by a vascular occlusion in the cat (for review, see Haouzi et al., 2004). An inhibition of many endings activated by muscle contractions has been found during the recovery phase of muscle contractions with vascular occlusion; the neural activity re-increases after releasing the arterial occlusion (Mense & Stahnke, 1983). In vivo, there is a large body of literature showing that vascular occlusion after complete cessation of the contractions produces a reduction and not a stimulation in breathing (Dejours et al., 1957; Fukuba et al., 2007; Haouzi et al., 1993; Innes et al., 1989). These observations triggered the search for a mechanism that could be sensitive to the level of perfusion in the muscle, mediated by distension of the vascular network. Such a circulatory signal to medullary neurons could be used as a surrogate for metabolism. (More details on this theory can be found in Haouzi et al., 2004.) The existence of this control system, along with all the other confounding physiological changes produced by a vascular occlusion, as described above, render vascular occlusion manoeuvres unsuitable to characterize the effects of the muscle metaboreflex on breathing. Of note, a decrease in , often observed during the occlusion manoeuvres, must consider the reduction in venous return/pulmonary blood flow and thus the distortion of CO2 expiratory profile between ‘occluded’ and ‘unoccluded’ recovery. A decreased slope of the CO2 ‘plateau’ during a reduction in pulmonary venous return can lead to a decrease in without reflecting a reduction in mean alveolar . This effect may even be magnified when breathing frequency increases. Increasing to compensate for the observed reduction in will not maintain isocapnia, but can create a misleading hypercapnic stimulus. Even if breathing were stimulated by a post-exercising limb vascular occlusion (which is not confirmed by many studies; Dejours et al., 1957; Fukuba et al., 2007; Haouzi et al., 1993; Innes et al., 1989), we would still know very little on the contribution of such a sensing mechanism during a dynamic exercise, as blood flow is elevated. Similarly, even if lactate and potassium levels (or other metabolic markers that one may consider) did rise in the muscles as exercise intensity increases, this situation would be very different from that created by an acute muscle ischaemia. How such a control mechanism could be applied to the ventilatory response during light or moderate exercise such as walking or running at moderate speed is still not clear. The mechanisms behind the stimulation of breathing produced by a complete vascular occlusion of a post-exercising limb following a moderate intensity exercise (or during contraction) may simply not be present during unobstructed contractions (see discussion in Haouzi, 2014). These points constitute the main limitations of the studies involving vascular occlusion in humans. A much more interesting experimental paradigm consists, for instance, in blocking, even partially, the afferent traffic while performing a ‘normal’ exercise. In the studies of Amann et al. (2010), in which a dynamic exercise is performed while inhibiting the afferent traffic at the spinal level, suggest that the contribution of limb afferent fibres (muscle, skin or tendons) – at least those with transduction in the spinal cord/dorsal roots with mu opioid-sensitive neurons – is more important during heavy exercise than during a moderate exercise. Unfortunately, the role of mechanoreception vs. metaboreception cannot be established from these studies. In conclusion, the effects of a vascular leg occlusion on breathing cannot be simply ascribed to one specific mechanism of action, such as the muscle metaboreflex. The multifarious and unpredictable effects on breathing elicited by a vascular occlusion make this approach unsuitable to identify the ventilatory effects of the muscle metaboreflex. The ventilatory effects of the muscle metaboreflex is also ‘hidden’ by inhibitory mechanisms produced by the occlusion manoeuvre. Certainly, vascular occlusion experiments were extremely important to perform and are now part of the history of the study of breathing control in exercise (Dejours et al., 1957). They did show us how ventilation responds to painful muscle ischaemia, i.e. ventilation goes up. Looking back at this literature, it is not clear whether these experiments have increased our understanding on the mechanisms of isocapnic ventilatory response to exercise, regardless of the talent and the curiosity of these great physiologists. None. Sole author.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Philippe Haouzi (2020) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: