Why the study?
Does pericardial drainage compared to repeat pericardial tap improve control of pericardial effusion in patients with malignant pericardial tamponade?
Does pericardial drainage compared to repeat pericardial tap improve control of pericardial effusion in patients with malignant pericardial tamponade?
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
In patients with malignant pericardial tamponade, immediate percutaneous or surgical drainage provides better sustained control of effusion compared to repeat pericardial taps.
We studied the clinical course and management of 27 patients with malignant pericardial tamponade seen in a single Medical Center over a 10 year period. Patients treated with repeat pericardial tap as their only mode of therapy had a high rate of recurrent tamponade (6 of 13 subjects) whereas most patients treated with drainage (either surgical or percutaneous) had sustained control of their pericardial effusion (achieved in 10/13 subjects). Intra-pericardial instillation of tetracycline or cyclophosphamide did not clearly improve the good results obtained with drainage alone. Extensive pericardiectomy was required in 2 patients only. Irrespective of the mode of therapy, survival was poor in patients with carcinoma of lung (N = 10) with a median survival of 30 days only vs. 135 days for patients with breast carcinoma (N = 10). Patients with malignant pericardial tamponade are best treated with immediate drainage. Percutaneous and sub-xiphoid surgical drainage are equally effective. Despite invasion of the pericardium by carcinoma, patients with a good oncologic prognosis may enjoy an appreciable survival with adequate quality of life following relief of tamponade.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Rinkevich et al. (1990) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: