Why the study?
Does tethered swimming alter cardio-pulmonary responses compared to land exercise in young swimmers?
Does tethered swimming alter cardio-pulmonary responses compared to land exercise in young swimmers?
During maximal work, the stimulus for adequate oxygen uptake is governed by work demand, overcoming physiological influences of water immersion or posture.
Tethered swimming may alter ventilatory responses versus land exercise in young swimmers; leaves open effects on training or safety pending prospective data.
Cardio-pulmonary response was compared in nine American swimmers (18-21 year) during tethered swimming and land exercise. VE was significantly higher in land (P<.05) than in swimming due to the higher f. At a comparable VO2 greater HR was observed in land exercise during submaximal work. However, during maximal work the difference disappeared. The DLco increased linearly with VO2 during land exercise but plateaued out during swimming so that compared to land DLco was higher in swimming at submaximal work. There was a linear increase in Vc with increase in VO2 in both swimming and land exercise. The Vc during swimming was significantly higher (P<.01) than that in land exercise over all work loads. During submaximalwork VE, HR, DLco, and Vc were affected by the water immersion and posture. However, during maximal work in spite of higher Vc in swimming the DLco was almost the same as that in land exercise. It was postulated that the stimulus for an adequate oxygen uptake is governed by the work demand which overcomes any influence from other sources such as water immersion or posture.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Takeo Nomura (1977) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: