Why the study?
Is continuous spinal anesthesia using 28-gauge microcatheters safe regarding neurologic complications and postdural puncture headache?
Is continuous spinal anesthesia using 28-gauge microcatheters safe regarding neurologic complications and postdural puncture headache?
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The author argues that continuous spinal anesthesia using 28-gauge catheters with a directional needle and isobaric local anesthetics is a safe practice that should not be restricted to high-risk patients.
To the Editor: Horlocker et al. [1] inserted 28-gauge microcatheters in 127 parturients using continuous spinal anesthesia (CSA) for pain relief. There was a 33% incidence of patients with postdural puncture headache (PDPH) and an 0.8% incidence of PDPH with neurologic complications in this group. The authors conclude that CSA is associated with an increased frequency of neurologic complications and should be reserved for high-risk patients. Since 1990, have inserted more than 1200 28-gauge catheters in more than 1100 patients without any neurologic complication. We are convinced that maldistribution of large doses of hyperbaric local anesthetics through presumably caudally directed microcatheters is responsible for the reported cases of cauda equina syndrome [2,3]. In a clinical study [4], we found that the subarachnoid position of microcatheters has a major impact on the onset of analgesia and the dose of local anesthetics, although we used isobaric local anesthetics. As a consequence, we recommend the insertion of microcatheters through a directional needle that provides a greater number of cranial catheter positions and reduces the number of paresthesias [5]. Following these recommendations, we routinely use a 22-gauge Sprotte needle and 28-gauge catheters in patients undergoing orthopedic or trauma surgery, regardless of age or gender. The high incidence of PDPH in Horlocker et al.'s [1] study can be explained by the group of patients (parturients) studied, which is known to have the greatest risk of this complication. We reported [6] our first 100 patients who received CSA using a microcatheter and a 22-gauge Quincke needle with a 1% incidence of PDPH. However, the mean age in our prospective study was 62.5 yr, compared with 29 yr in Horlocker's retrospective study. The authors could have significantly reduced their incidence of PDPH by using atraumatic needles, because a meta-analysis has shown that the frequency of PDPH depends on needle size and design [7]. Nevertheless, we prefer epidurals or combined spinal/epidural anesthesia over microcatheter CSA in obstetrics. In conclusion, we feel that CSA using 28-gauge catheters with a directional needle and isobaric local anesthetics is a safe practice that should not be restricted to high-risk patients.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Thomas Standl (1998) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: