Why the study?
Does the needle-through-needle CSE method reduce the incidence of paraesthesia and neural damage compared to the double-barrel method in patients receiving spinal anaesthesia?
Does the needle-through-needle CSE method reduce the incidence of paraesthesia and neural damage compared to the double-barrel method in patients receiving spinal anaesthesia?
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The needle-through-needle CSE technique appears safe with a low incidence of paraesthesia and neural damage, challenging claims that fine-gauge pencil point needles are inherently unsafe.
We read with interest and concern the letter to Anaesthesia (1997; 53: 411) by Drs Collier and Turner who have ‘… virtually abandoned the use of a combined spinal epidural (CSE) technique with pencil point needles’, implying that these needles are unsafe. We suggest that their conclusion is unfounded and that it is most likely their CSE technique which is at fault. Your correspondents referred to a letter by Turner and Shaw who observed paraesthesia in 6 out of 36 patients having CSE anaesthesia for Caesarean section [1]. One of the six had a dysaesthesia some 6 months after the procedure. We assume that the CSE technique used was the ‘double-barrel’ method advocated by Turner and Reifenberg, a method which involves inserting a fine (25G) Whitacre needle via a short introducer, through the interspinous ligament, ligamentum flavum and epidural space to reach the theca [2]. This technique of spinal needle insertion is associated with a high incidence of needle deflection, misdirection and damage [3456]. Undoubtedly the best way to minimise such damage is to avoid passing the fine-gauge needle through these tissues. In other words, insertion should be through a Tuohy (or other similar, blunt) needle first sited in the epidural space. This is the basis of the needle-through-needle CSE method, which is arguably the most widely used CSE technique today. Almost all the studies cited in a recent comprehensive review of CSE used this needle-through-needle method [7], a technique which has been used at Queen Charlotte's Hospital in more than 11 000 patients since 1991. Most of those blocks were administered to obstetric and gynaecological patients by trainees and to the best of our knowledge no problems involving damaged 27G Whitacre needles have been encountered. A recent audit of 1000 consecutive CSEs performed at Queen Charlotte's Hospital indicates an incidence of paraesthesia of 6% with one case of an associated short-term dysaesthesia. Paraesthesia reported by a patient during epidural and/or spinal or other regional procedure should always be recorded, accorded some concern and the patient followed-up postoperatively; but paraesthesia per se does not imply neural damage. Dysaesthesia, hypoaesthesia and similar sequelae can result from CSE where no paraesthesia is observed [8]. The significance of paraesthesiae associated with all lumbar puncture techniques has not been satisfactorily resolved with respect to spinal needle type or insertion method used. But, as your correspondents report, incidences of paraesthesia of up to 27% have been reported for needle-through-tissues techniques [3] and the extra depth of thecal insertion of pencil-point needles does require further investigation [2]. Your correspondents' anecdotes and an audit of 36 administrations are not a sound basis to conclude that paraesthesiae axiomatically indicate neurotrauma due to these needles. We submit that the needle-through-needle CSE technique is emerging as a most important advance in anaesthetic practice and pain management. Like all regional anaesthetic procedures CSE is not without unexpected hazards and these and other aspects of all techniques of lumbar puncture require further study.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Crowhurst et al. (1998) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: