Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
To the Editor —A recent publication by Fidock et al. [1] reported a perfect correlation between the chloroquine-resistant (CQR) phenotype in Plasmodium falciparum and sequence polymorphisms in pfcrt [1]. A mutation, K76T, in pfcrt was shown to be present in all CQR isolates and absent from all chloroquine-susceptible (CQS) isolates tested. Besides K76T, all tested CQR parasites have multiple additional mutations, in various arrangements, at positions 72, 74, 75, 97, 220, 271, 326, 356, and 371 [1]. We wondered whether the same perfect correlation between the K76T mutation and chloroquine resistance would be observed if we used a different set of isolates and whether the additional mutations might possibly be related to different levels of chloroquine resistance. We attempted to answer these questions by determining chloroquine susceptibilities and sequence polymorphisms in pfcrt in parasite isolates collected from Bougainville, an island province of Papua New Guinea, and Thailand and in 15 parasite lines available in our laboratory The Bougainville isolates (AN*, 33 samples) were collected from the Arawa, Buka, and Konga areas from December 1998 through March 1999, and the Thai isolates (AA*, 3 samples) were collected from the Thai-Myanmar border area in July 1998. The susceptibilities of the parasite isolates to chloroquine were measured using the standard in vitro assay recommended by the World Health Organization [2]. DNA was extracted from the parasite samples, and the pfcrt gene was amplified by polymerase chain reaction and sequenced Polymorphisms in pfcrt at 10 codon positions are summarized in table 1. Of these codons, T76 and S220 were found in all samples that were classified as CQR by in vitro testing (MIC, ⩾8 pmol/well), but they were not found in any laboratory lines classified as CQS by in vitro testing (MIC, <8 pmol/well). The CQS lines contained only K76 and A220. The results are in good agreement with those reported by Fidock et al. [1], suggesting that K76T and A220S might be essential for conferring chloroquine resistance and that pfcrt plays an important role in chloroquine resistance Correlation between sequence polymorphism in PfCRT and in vitro chloroquine susceptibility Polymorphisms at positions 74, 75, 271, 326, 356, and 371 were linked into blocks in our collection of samples. M74/N75/Q271/D326/L356/R371 was found in all Bougainville samples, and I74/E75/E271/S326/T(I)356/I371 was found in all but 1 Thai sample (INDO19). The Bougainville isolates have the block of codons identical to those of 7G8, a parasite line originating from Brazil. Fidock et al. [1] sequenced pfcrt in 6 CQR lines from Brazil, including 7G8, and found the same allele type. Therefore, these blocks are likely to be associated with the geographical origins of the parasite. This suggests that the CQR parasites from Bougainville and Brazil might be derived from a common origin In our set of samples, chloroquine susceptibilities (MICs) of the CQR isolates ranged from 8 to >64 pmol/well. No association was found between the levels of chloroquine resistance and sequence polymorphism at any of the 10 positions (table 1). Therefore, other mechanisms on different loci are likely to modulate the level of chloroquine resistance One of the candidate mechanisms is the cg2 gene. Sequence polymorphisms in cg2 which includes 12-point mutations, 3 repetitive sequences (κ, γ, and ω), and a poly-Asn tract, have been proposed to be associated with chloroquine resistance [3]. Several studies suggested that polymorphisms in cg2 especially κ and ω repeats, were associated with chloroquine resistance, although the polymorphisms do not adequately discriminate CQR parasites from CQS parasites [4–7 ]. To determine whether sequence polymorphisms in cg2 modulate the level of chloroquine resistance, we examined cg2 sequences in the same set of isolates. No sequence polymorphism or repetitive sequence arrangement in cg2 was found to correlate with in vitro chloroquine susceptibility, suggesting that cg2 may not be directly involved in the development or modulation of chloroquine resistance. The previously reported correlation could have resulted from the physically close location of cg2 and pfcrt on chromosome 7. As with pfcrt the codon changes appeared to be linked into blocks and were associated with the origins of the parasite samples (data not shown). Again, Bougainville isolates presented patterns similar to 7G8, and most of the Thai isolates showed patterns similar to Dd2 As for Bougainville, the CQR pfcrt genotypes (T76 and S220) were detected in all isolates, which is in good agreement with the CQR phenotype determined by in vitro assays, indicating that CQR P. falciparum is widespread in this region. The CQS pfcrt genotype (K76 and A220) was detected in only 5 of the 33 samples, and all were mixed with CQR genotypes (table 1), a finding that was not possible to detect by use of the in vitro assay. The result shows that the sequence changes of K76T and A220S may be useful as a genetic marker to monitor chloroquine resistance in the field
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Chen et al. (2001) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: