Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This analysis reveals that Mohism's failure in competition stemmed from low kernel inheritability, despite high structural completeness.
English Abstract: During the Warring States period, Mohism and Confucianism were both "prominent schools," yet their historical fates diverged drastically. Conventional explanations attribute Mohism's failure to its "idealism" or its representation of "small producers," failing to uncover deeper mechanisms. This paper employs the three core models of the "Productive Political Philosophy" framework to systematically address this intellectual-historical paradox in two parts. Part I diagnoses Mohism and Confucianism using the Political Philosophy Cohesion Model and the Dynamic Success Probability Model: Mohism was a fully cohesive system (Ω=0.81, active synthesis), yet its efficiency coefficient (η) could not be activated within Zhou patriarchal society; Early Confucianism was structurally incomplete (Ω=0.09, passive synthesis), yet its η was partially released in the agricultural era. The Dynamic Success Probability Model reveals that Mohism possessed extremely high Structural Completeness (S) and Leadership (L), but near-zero Kernel Inheritability (H); Early Confucianism possessed moderate S and L, but extremely high H, with objective conditions overwhelmingly favorable. The paper's core thesis is that in short-term competition, Kernel Inheritability (H) takes precedence over Structural Completeness (S). Part II asks a deeper question: why was Mohism's H near zero? The answer is that Mohism was not a utopian fantasy, but a systematic response to the failures of the Shang theocratic system. Each of its core tenets—Heaven's Will, Universal Love, Identification with the Superior, Exaltation of the Worthy, Frugal Burial, Opposition to Music, and Opposition to Aggression—targeted specific problems of the late Shang. Uniquely among the Hundred Schools, Mohism consciously integrated science and technology into its philosophical core. But Mohism arrived six hundred years too late. When it emerged, the Shang world no longer existed. The Community Cohesion Model traces this back to the Shang as a "loosely allied polycentric community (Type II)," with the Shang-Zhou transition resulting from climatic selection between two community types. This paper proposes a testable analytical model for ideological competition, rather than offering definitive conclusions.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
鑫培 骆 (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: