Key result
The spontaneous and sequence methods for assessing baroreflex function did not provide reliable or valid data comparable to the traditional pharmacological method in resting rats.
Spontaneous and sequence methods for assessing baroreflex function are not reliable or valid alternatives to the traditional pharmacological method in resting, normotensive rats under the studied conditions.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Spontaneous/sequence baroreflex methods unreliable vs pharmacological in resting rats; leaves open validation in disease models or other species.
The function of the arterial baroreflex has traditionally been assessed by measurement of reflex changes in heart rate (HR) or sympathetic nerve activity resulting from experimenter-induced manipulation of arterial blood pressure (the Oxford method, also termed the pharmacological method). However, logistical and flexibility limitations of this technique have promoted the development of new methods for assessing baroreflex function such as the evaluation of changes in spontaneous arterial pressure and HR. Although this new spontaneous method has been validated in dogs and humans, it has not been rigorously tested in rats. In the present study, the method of correlating spontaneous changes in systolic blood pressure and HR was evaluated in resting, normotensive Sprague-Dawley rats. This technique was found to be neither reliable nor valid under the conditions employed in the present protocol. We also tested a variation of the spontaneous method that evaluates particular sequences of data during which arterial pressure and pulse interval are changing in the same direction for at least three consecutive heartbeats (the sequence method). The sequence method did not provide extra reliability or validity over the spontaneous method. We conclude that due to the restricted range of variability obtained by measuring spontaneous blood pressure fluctuations, the spontaneous and sequence techniques do not provide data that are comparable to the traditional method of assessing HR changes triggered by arterial blood pressure increases and decreases induced by vasoactive drugs. However, it is possible that surgical stress obscured the relationship between blood pressure and HR, and therefore additional studies are needed to determine whether the spontaneous and sequence methods can be applied to rats during different behavioral states.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Moffitt et al. (2005) studied Normotensive. Spontaneous and sequence methods vs. Traditional Oxford method (pharmacological method) was evaluated on Reliability and validity of correlating spontaneous changes in systolic blood pressure and heart rate. The spontaneous and sequence methods for assessing baroreflex function did not provide reliable or valid data comparable to the traditional pharmacological method in resting rats.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: