Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
I read with great interest the article by Amoils and coauthors1 about keratectasia formation after laser in situ keratomileusis (LASIK). While it is imperative that the dangers and risks of LASIK be recognized and acknowledged, this article requires critical comments because of its descriptive and rather unscientific nature. The authors did not operate on the patients and may not have received all the data on every patient. Unfortunately, the article has enjoyed publicity in various media. For proper evaluation of the risk of post-LASIK keratectasia, we need the following information at the least: initial refraction and topography data using the same topographer and program; preoperative and postoperative pachymetry; laser and microkeratome information; flap thickness measurement and topography 2 to 4 weeks post-LASIK; and comment on the possible existence of cataract. In this study, it was difficult to compare the topography maps of patients; eg, Figures 8B and 8C of patient 8 in which either the programs or the devices varied. Postoperative (2 weeks to 1 month) topography should also be required to show what really happened before the possible tissue reactions or enhancements occurred. Flaps that are too thick may be formed with some microkeratomes, leaving a thin stromal bed. Only the bed is responsible for the corneal rigidity. Nuclear sclerosis should be carefully monitored because it may lead to misinterpretations and unnecessary enhancements. Unhealthy eyes should not be operated on. Table 2 shows that cases 5 and 6 had keratoconus preoperatively. These patients should not have been operated on. Patient 1 had an inferior steepening up to 46.0 diopters (D) (looks different on the “absolute” map than on the postoperative “normalized” Tomey map). This asymmetry became more evident after the elliptic photoablation performed to correct the with-the-rule cylinder. This patient had a reasonable postoperative corneal thickness. The asymmetry of his cornea, which preoperatively showed characteristics of early keratoconus, was only enhanced by the operation. Maybe patient 1 did not develop an ectasia after all. Patient 4 had a preoperative topography that showed astigmatism of almost 4.0 D and a pattern resembling central keratoconus with a K-value of 48.1 D in the steepest meridian. The postoperative pattern is the same but with an increased maximal K-value and astigmatism, suggesting development of central keratectasia. Retrospectively, patients 1, 4, 5, and 6 (6 eyes) should not have been operated on because of the possibility of keratoconus. Patients 2 (left eye), 3 (both eyes, left eye enhanced), 7 (both eyes), and 8 (left eye, enhanced twice) also had remarkably thinner corneas postoperatively than they should have had according to Table 2. These 6 eyes had a calculated stromal bed thickness between 175 and 222 μm, assuming that the flap was 160 μm thick. Although the flaps are known to be thinner than targeted, the integrity of the cornea may have been surgically compromised. Patient 3 had similar refractions in both eyes. If one assumes that the preoperative topography maps were also similar to each other (only left one was shown), there was an 8.0 D change in preoperative versus 3 month central topographies, which would mean that the patient received a significant (approximately −3.0 D) overcorrection. The postoperative topographies of patients 2 (left eye) and 3 (both eyes) show a well-documented central keratectasia. The relatively old laser nomograms used also caused relatively deep photoablations compared to those caused by more modern nomograms. Laser in situ keratomileusis induces a long-lasting sensory neural damage, which may be related to postoperative neurotropic problems. Each enhancement reverses any neural recovery and may induce further keratocyte death. Studies by Vesaluoma et al.2 and Wilson and Kim3 confirm that keratocyte apoptosis takes place on both sides of the flap interface. I believe that reports such as this paper, although important and interesting, should not be left without critical evaluation because they might lead to confusion among the media, patients, regulatory organs, optometrists, other medical personnel, and our fellow ophthalmologists. On the contrary, this report should stimulate us to document our patients and procedures better to enable reconstruction of the preoperative and postoperative events in a way that makes scientific conclusions about the risk and etiology of post-LASIK keratectasia possible. The conclusions that can be drawn on the basis of this article are as follows: watch for signs of keratoconus, do not operate on keratoconus patients, watch for thin stromal beds, reconsider the enhancements, and document the patients carefully. Timo M Tervo MD aHelsinki, Finland
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Timo Tervo (2001) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: