Why the study?
Does the pulse-contour method accurately determine stroke volume compared to indicator-dilution methods in patients with ischemic heart disease or mitral valve disease?
Does the pulse-contour method accurately determine stroke volume compared to indicator-dilution methods in patients with ischemic heart disease or mitral valve disease?
The pulse-contour method correlates well with indicator-dilution for stroke volume but has a 20% coefficient of variation, making it useful for rapid monitoring but not for detecting small changes.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Pulse-contour estimates show moderate agreement with dilution methods in ischemic or mitral disease; leaves open precision for serial monitoring.
The pulse-contour method for determining stroke volume has been employed as a continuous rapid method of monitoring the cardiovascular status of patients. Twenty-one patients with ischemic heart disease and 21 patients with mitral valve disease were subjected to a variety of hemodynamic interventions. These included exercise, isoproterenol infusion, and practolol, morphine or pentazocine administration. The pulse-contour estimations, using three different formulae derived by Warner, Kouchoukos, and Herd, were compared with indicator-dilution outputs. The pressure-pulse-contour computations were performed by a small on-line cardiac catheterization laboratory computer. A comparison of the results of the two methods for determining stroke volume yielded correlation coefficients ranging from 0.59 to 0.84. The better performing Warner formula yielded a coefficient of variation of about 20%. The type of hemodynamic interventions employed did not significantly affect the results using the pulse-contour method. This method yielded nearly as reliable results with the catheter positioned in the axillary artery as in the central aorta. Good results were obtained using the pulse-contour method in patients with atrial fibrillation as compared to those with sinus rhythm. Although the correlation of the pulse-contour and indicator-dilution stroke volumes is high, the coefficient of variation is such that small changes in stroke volume cannot be accurately assessed by the pulse-contour method. However, the simplicity and rapidity of this method compared to determination of cardiac output by Fick or indicator-dilution methods makes it a potentially useful adjunct for monitoring critically ill patients.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Alderman et al. (1972) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: