Why the study?
Inconsistencies exist in provider application of the ASA-PS classification, and there is limited research on how to improve inter-rater agreement.
Does an educational intervention improve inter-rater agreement of the ASA-PS classification system between medicine and anesthesia providers?
Does an educational intervention improve inter-rater agreement of the ASA-PS classification system between medicine and anesthesia providers?
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
An educational intervention for medicine providers improved ASA-PS classification agreement with anesthesiologists from slight to moderate, though the change was not statistically significant.
INTRODUCTION: The American Society of Anesthesiologists' Physical Status (ASA-PS) Classification System was established to grade a patient's physical status prior to surgery. The literature shows inconsistencies in the application of the ASA-PS classification among providers. The many uses of the ASA-PS class require reliable ASA-PS class designations between providers. While much literature illustrates the inconsistency, there is limited research on how to improve inter-rater agreement. MATERIAL AND METHODS: Following an educational intervention targeted at medicine providers, a retrospective chart review was completed to determine the long-term impact of an educational intervention on ASA-PS class agreement among providers of different specialties. To assess the overall agreement between the data sets following the intervention, kappa statistics were calculated for the medicine and anesthesia data sets. These values were compared to the kappa statistics from a similar study completed prior to the educational intervention. RESULTS: Overall, the kappa score, or agreement, between medicine and anesthesia providers improved from the range generally accepted to indicate slight agreement to the range indicating moderate agreement. CONCLUSIONS: While there was improvement in agreement following an education intervention, the agreement seen was not statistically significant. More research needs to be done to determine how to improve inter-rater reliability of the ASA-PS classification system with a focus on non-anesthesia providers.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Knuf et al. (2019) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: