Key points are not available for this paper at this time.
Design
Editorial
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This letter critiques a prior study on V̇O2 kinetics in heart failure, emphasizing the need for appropriate noninvasive respiratory analysis techniques over single monoexponential fitting.
Dear Editor-in-Chief: We applaud Arena et al. (1) for acknowledging that derangements of O2 transport and utilization in HF slow V̇O2 kinetics at exercise onset. Arena et al. (1) “compare mean response time (MRT) and time constant (TC) calculations, using breath-by-breath (bxb) and averaged data in HF...” and in so doing cite the seminal studies of Whipp in 1971 (7). Unfortunately, they (1) have neglected to either recognize or utilize key physiological, technical and theoretical advances made in the intervening three decades: incorporation of which would increase the applicability and validity of their study. Whipp’s work (7) provides a remarkable foundation for our understanding of pulmonary gas exchange and systems control. However, the analysis system used allowed mixed expired gas analysis every 30 s. Modern bxb technology permits resolution of three discrete phases of the V̇O2 on-transient response to moderate exercise (e.g., 8). Unfortunately, the inherent noisiness of bxb responses raises the following crucial issues: V̇O2 measured from expired gases alone is insensitive to changes in lung gas stores across the exercise on-transient and pulmonary V̇O2 may underestimate alveolar V̇O2 by 44% (2). A simple monoexponential fit to the V̇O2 on-transient response is inappropriate from a theoretical construct and analysis of residuals (8). To resolve different phases of the V̇O2 on-transient, several tests must be averaged (5,8). Comparison between TC and MRT (1) simply compares the fitting of a single exponential with the actual physiological response, which incorporates a delay-like component that precedes the exponential. In addition, the following concerns are pertinent: a) Was ejection fraction the only criterion of heart failure assessment? Documented disease doesn’t mean the patient has HF per se. They may have LV dysfunction without deficiencies in exercise capacity and/or V̇O2max? Into what classification (class I–IV;6) do these subjects fall? b) Is a patient for whom moderate exercise constitutes a V̇O2 of ∼1.8 L·min−1 equal to the maximal V̇O2 of healthy age-matched sedentary subjects (N = 2256;4) representative of the congestive heart failure population? If the subject in Figure 3 (1) weighs ∼75 kg, the V̇O2 achieved for moderate exercise is 20–45% higher than the V̇O2max of congestive heart failure patients (6)! c) The slow component may or may not (3) be independent of V̇O2 on-kinetics. In conclusion, Figure 3 of Arena et al. (1) demonstrates that a single monoexponential fit cannot provide an appropriate fit to the V̇O2 response. Thus, one might reasonably ask how much error in the estimate of the temporal V̇O2 response arises from each technique. Such a study would necessarily incorporate consideration of issues 1–3 (vide supra) and resolve the accurate temporal profile of gas exchange thereby permitting direct measurement of error. This analysis is necessary to establish whether or not “... different calculations . . . may accurately represent physiology.. . .” We disagree strongly with the proposal that: “Additional work is needed, with more invasive techniques, to determine which . . . calculation is most representative of true physiology” (1). A more sensible and rigorous approach might be to use noninvasive respiratory analysis correctly (3) and spare the patient the discomfort of an unnecessary and ethically questionable invasive procedure. Brad J. Behnke Paul McDonough Timothy I. Musch David C. Poole
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Behnke et al. (2003) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: